I'm confused. Are you wondering which is the more "Marshally" tone? They're both very Marshally. If it's just for you jamming without accompaniment, it's really down to personal preference; which one puts a bigger grin on your face. And that could vary depending on what kind of music you're playing, or even from day to day, depending on your mood. I'd be happy noodling around with either one.Just to be a bit clearer here (and thanks for chiming in BTW) I am not looking for "better" or mix related opinions. Basically it's just you looking for a Marshall type tone as you would expect it and as you might want to sit around and jam on.
On it's own, number 2!