Nothing wrong with picking something that works for you. That's the point of having so many options. That said, have you even bothered trying an OD in front? As noted, they are well known for being 'loose' with nothing else in the signal path (google mesa rectifier loose gain). All this hype you have heard about them is likely regarding tones recorded/performed with an OD to condition the signal, etc. This is all many people need with one in real life... maybe it'll help you see what the fuss is all about; maybe you just don't like them.
The main thing to me personally is that the models are accurate and that we have enough to choose from to get where we want. Even if that accuracy means it does something we don't prefer because that may be just what someone else is looking for and there are plenty of choices in the box.
Yeah, in my original post I said I had gotten it to sound decent with a lot of advanced tweaks plus Drive in front and PEQ after but my point was, why go through all that when you can get (IMO) a better tone from other amps without all the fuss? Speaking for myself only, I just don't see the point of going through all that trouble when you can just pick an amp that has the tone you want already there and ready to go with minimal tweaking. For me, the ENGL Savage, 5150 III Red and CarolAnn Triptik Modern are my go-to amps. I have yet to dive into the Diezel, Bogner or Cornford models but I have heard they are good as well. Then again, I am a high-gain metal only player so all of the myriad host of Fender Deluxe this and that are lost on me as well!