MikeyB59 said:I'm not on the list yet, but I'm psyched. I've convinced myself to live with my current solutions for the time being and wait for the verdict on the Fracta/Atomic solution. One of my biggest revelations in sound came when I purchased a Scott 60's tube integrated amp (299c I think) in the early 90's. I had some pretty nice solid state stuff, a Harmon Kardon 100 wpc SS power amp and a Phase Linear SS preamp. I put on a Sonny Rollins album. It sounded like a recording of a sax on the SS gear. I switched out and ran the Scott. It sounded like Sonny Rollins in my living room.
That's why I'm really psyched that they chose to use a tube power section. I think they might've been able to achieve the sense of "realism" with a SS solution, but I think tubes, particularly in the power section bring a presence and aliveness that's just harder to do with SS. I was taking lessons a few years ago from Mike Elliott who was the top jazz guitarist in the Minneapolis area in the 60's and 70's. He later moved to Nashville and was a session guy for a bunch of years. While I was studying with him, he did a jazz album where he played all the parts with midi. It is a pretty amazing accomplishment even if some of the sounds are a little cheesy. What he was really proud of though was the guitar tone which he thought sounded as good as any jazz guitar tone ever recorded. He had a fairly complicated signal chain for his guitar and it did sound really great. It was all tracked direct. What I do remember is that he used a Fender stereo tube power amp (can't remember model...Red-faced Twin era thing) and a Hughes and Kettner Redbox as part of the signal chain.
He'd talk about how all the people doing solid state amps with tube preamps had things completely ass backwards in terms of where it was important to have the tubes. I tend to agree. I love my Musicman amps and they're solid state front end, tube power. So, I'm delighted they used tubes. If they hadn't, I probably would've bought a Verve 8ma or 12ma. As it is, I'm making do with a Tech 21 Power Wedge 60 and a couple of ok powered monitors and waiting for the reports.
Mike
So what you are saying is that if Fratomic had been SS, you would have bought a different SS solution? That doesn't really make much sense.