As others said, the only thing i can say is the first one is slightly better, which does not mean it is the axe or it is not ^^
Here's the answer folks: first is Axe Fx second is EVH!
I have to mention that I could get this close only by setting the same values on both EVH and Axe, if I changed Bass/Mid/Treble/Depth/Presence by 0.5 the difference was more perceivable. This means that the Axe is spot-on compared to its real counterpart!
Gain is a little different though, real version was at 8 and had to set the Axe at 4.7 or something like that, maybe if I disconnected the "Saturation" switch on the Axe it would have been 8 too, who knows.
Another reason why I could get this close is because both real amp and Axe were fed by the same guitar DI signal, which is basically like playing them at the same time.
Anyway glad you liked it
Would you share the patch now ?