They All Sound the Same Again

[FractalAudio]

Two modelers, one amp:
https://www.fractalaudio.com/tmp/camera.mp3

 

[Velokki]

Amp 1 = Axe 3, Amp 2 = whatever competing product

 

[Mott]

Well I sure hope the 3rd one wasn't the Fractal.

Overall, 1 sounded slightly better to my ears than 2 but awful close. I'd be happy with either of those.

 

[JoKeR III]

There's a clear difference between all three. Not being familiar with the actual amp makes this one a crapshoot for me but I prefer #2 purely from a tone point of view. 1 became more harsh after a few times through, 3 sounded/felt similar to 2 but with much less high end.

 

[ruso]

Two modelers, one amp:
https://www.fractalaudio.com/tmp/camera.mp3

1. Real Amp
2. Axe-FX
3. Potato covered with a blanket

 

[JTI]

3 is very muffled sounding comparatively. That's as much of a guess as you're going to get from me.

 

[Hapless]

I preferred the second one. The third one sounded like there was a blanket over it. The first one was ok.

 

[∞Fractals]

1. Real Amp
2. Axe-FX
3. Potato covered with a blanket

If I had to …

That’s what it seems.


Digging the A. Lifeson jams

 

[mr_fender]

1 and 2 have very similar character, but 1 is brighter and 2 is fatter. 3 is muddy and flubby.

I think 1 and 2 are the amp and Axe FX (no idea which is which).

 

[Spartacus]

First two are closest, so I guess these are amp and axe. No idea of order.

 

[Andrew Male]

3rd one sounds like a pillow was put in front of the mic, 1 and 2 very similar.

I'd say:

1. amp
2. axe
3. Algorithmically Perfect (TM)?

 

[merlin17]

1 sounds best (clear and cutting but not unpleasant), 2 sounds similar but not as forward and clear, 3 is useless.

 

[Triaxis75]

I cant tell, being unfamiliar with the actual amp. 1 and 2 are closest, so I'd assume Axe & Amp for those in whichever order. The 3rd is just painfully far away from the other two. Seemed pretty easy to dispel it.

 

[JebHowell]

1. Amp
2. Axe FX
3. Other modeler

 

[54321pj]

Axe
Amp
Other modeler (or someone threw the cabinet in the swimming pool)

 

[∞Fractals]

Amp
Axe
What I do in toilets

Mud?

 

[SacredGroove]

They all sound different. I'm guessing the axe III isn't one of them, since one of them is the real amp.

 

[shemihazazel]

1. Sounds like there's a little more high end sparkle.
2. Sounds slightly grittier by comparison.
3.

 

[Fjelltronen]

Amp
Axe
What I do in toilets

Play a guitar through an amp with a blanket over it? Probably a good place to do so as it could be quite a fire risk.

 

[AlbertA]

1. Amp
2. axe-fx
3. something else?