Nanoscientists Create ‘molecular’ Tube Emulator

Rane

Experienced
Not sure what to think of this. It sounds like a really cool idea, but I sorta' doubt - especially at this early stage - that it will provide a meaningful emulation of a serious modeling or tube rig.

Right now they only have an overdrive and fuzz pedal. It looks like they offer the technology for manufacturers/developers of other products to purchase as well.

The cell phone sim card looking things are the "Nanolog" chips:

20170122_132516_HDR.jpg


For years, serious guitar players have clung to their tube amplifiers, saying the rich sound is worth the hassle of old-school electronics.

Now, scientists at the University of Alberta have used the latest nanotechnology in a guitar pedal that duplicates that beloved warmth without the inconvenience and expense.

“People generally use the word ‘warmer,'” said Rick McCreery, a University of Alberta chemistry professor and researcher at Edmonton’s National Institute for Nanotechnology.

Most consumer electronics, including non-tube guitar amps, depend on silicon-based devices called transistors or diodes. They work extremely well to help amplify electronic signals accurately and smoothly.

Too accurately, for many finely tuned musical ears. The sound of silicon lacks the rich harmonics and overtones added when a signal goes through a non-linear circuit, such as a tube.

“If you take an ordinary electric guitar and just amplify it, then guitarists would say this is sterile,” McCreery said. “Guitarists didn’t like the silicon because it was too linear, too accurate. It didn’t generate nice harmonics.”

Tubes, however, are fragile and expensive to replace.

Adam Bergren, McCreery’s colleague and an amateur guitarist, knew that. He also knew that electronic circuits at the molecular scale have characteristics different from the straight-line response of silicon. At that scale, the rules of physics are different.

Together, they and their colleagues developed a circuit just a couple of molecules – billionths of a metre – thick. The team eventually created a non-linear circuit in a guitar pedal that responded just like a tube.

That pedal, dubbed the “Nanolog” and built in Edmonton, is already commercially available. It makes its industry debut this week at the National Association of Music Manufacturers in California, the largest such trade show in the world.

McCreery said their new business, Nanolog Audio, hopes to sell complete pedals and license the nanocircuitry to industry majors such as Fender or Boss.

The guitar pedal market is worth $100 million a year in the U.S. alone.

McCreery says the Nanolog is one of the very first consumer products available to use this type of nanotechnology. A previous pedal, called the Heisenberg and also developed in Edmonton, was released last year on a limited basis.

Guitar heroes are far from the only possible beneficiary from this type of circuit, said McCreery. Durable and reasonably priced, it could replace silicon in thousands of pieces of consumer electronics from stereo amps to cellphones.

Unlike silicon, the nanoscale circuit can be tuned to reflect whatever characteristics manufacturers desire, he said.

The Nanolog also underscores the importance of basic scientific research. McCreery said the first patents on the circuit date back to 2004 and researchers were working in the field for years before that.

“Basic research can have a fairly long incubation period,” he said.

“I never intended to make music devices when I started doing this. It’s not easy to tell what basic research is going to do for you.”

Sources:

http://globalnews.ca/news/3587496/u...ate-commercial-molecular-product-for-guitars/

https://www.nanologaudio.com/
 
Last edited:
Interesting... I suspect the potential outside the guitar world could be very big. Lots of other audio applications.
 
Interesting... I suspect the potential outside the guitar world could be very big. Lots of other audio applications.

Yeah, I was just thinking that a tube mic with one of these would be awesome.

Are nano-scientists very small scientists?

One billionth of a standard-issue scientist, to be exact. Can also refer the education level of the scientist. The later usage is all but nonexistent due to the prevalence of more popular and descriptive words. "Hobo," "special needs," "politician," and “journalist” being a few obvious examples.
 
Last edited:
It's the latest in a long line of "revolutionary" products developed by university guys with visions of $$$. I wish them luck, but only time will prove their designs.
 
Complete marketing BS. If you want a carbon based conductor you don't need nanotechnology. Get an old carbon based resistor.

My initial thought was that this was a transistor or op-amp alternative, but after taking a closer look, it seems that it's being used more like a diode clipping stage.

I just emailed them. They seem to be open to selling just the "Nanolog" component. Not sure if they'll sell it to just some random hobbyist, but it's worth a shot.
 
It's interesting to see that they can tailor non-linear curves/transfer functions in a solid state component; am curious to hear what it sounds like.

Emulating tubes is one thing; it's the way tubes dynamically interact with the surrounding circuitry and other amp blocks that gives a tube amp it's 'life', especially the power amp.

Would make for a nice overdrive/preamp if they do indeed mimic a high voltage tube circuit/curve in a solid state pedal. They may even develop some new types of useful curves that would differ from conventional solid state devices currently used for clipping (LEDs, FETS, etc.) in pedals.
 
Last edited:
It's interesting to see that they can tailor non-linear curves/transfer functions in a solid state component; am curious to hear what it sounds like.

Emulating tubes is one thing; it's the way tubes dynamically interact with the surrounding circuitry and other amp blocks that gives a tube amp it's 'life', especially the power amp.

Would make for a nice overdrive/preamp if they do indeed mimic a high voltage tube circuit/curve in a solid state pedal. They may even develop some new types of useful curves that would differ from conventional solid state devices currently used for clipping (LEDs, FETS, etc.) in pedals.

Yeah, I'd really like to hear it, but $400 is a bit steep. Especially since I don't even use pedals. They sold out their stock, so hopefully we'll hear some reviews/opinions in the coming weeks.
 
Those 'conductors' they put on a plastic SIM card look suspiciously like SMD resistors or diodes. Honestly, who would spend loads of money on nanotechnology to then use it to build and sell a couple of hundred drive pedals?
 
I get a little uneasy when someone develops new audio technology but does not have an easily accessible audio clip showcasing such technology.

To me that reminds me of the saying, "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is."
 
Can also refer the education level of the scientist. The later usage is all but nonexistent due to the prevalence of more popular and descriptive words. "Hobo," "special needs," "politician," and “journalist” being a few obvious examples.
ROFL :)

Thanks man - in the future I will at least think of myself as a micro scientist....
 
I just got a response back from them. The chip is used just like a diode clipping circuit. Very basic. Honestly, I don't think this is a tube emulation at all, but rather an interesting new clipping method.

What was mentioned earlier about the complexity of emulating not just a tube but it's whole interaction within an amp's circuitry is worth mentioning again. This could offer the pedal board geeks yet another interesting drive flavor - perhaps even a "tube-like" one. I don't think it's any step forward in tube modeling however.

They said they're not currently selling individual chips, but may do so in the near future. The price was estimated to be about $75 per chip with discounts for larger orders.

Quite steep for something that I suspect is -not- a revolution in tone. Still, I'd be curious enough to buy one and incorporate it into a known drive circuit. I'd make it switchable with standard diode clipping for an easy A/B tone comparison. If it's unique enough, perhaps Cliff would want to model one. ;)
 
SIM cards? Really? What a bizarre choice of form factor. Sure lets take two tiny diodes and package them so they take up 50 times as much PCB space. I'm sure compact pedal designers will love that idea.
 
Back
Top Bottom