solo-act
Fractal Fanatic
You're describing a need for instant random access to any preset/bank. That's a non-linear concept. Unfortunately, from what I've seen, all the foot switches out there are locked into a linear system.I'm surprised how many of you are doing a preset per song. I tried this when running an fx8 and the problems were one: we Segway songs together seamlessly in many occasions and is awkward to try to switch, and two: the song list always changes sometimes mid show. A special guest shows up, or a singer is not feeling a song, etc.
As a result, if number of presets and number of song list changes are both high, you're screwed. What do players/bands do? They either reduce number of presets or number changes to song list, or both. IMO, that's a compromise that shouldn't be happening. This is why I run with http://gordius.be/midi-footcontroller-lg.php
At my request, the programmer added a 10-key function. Punch in the number for your bank or preset and you're there -- instant random access -- non-linear.
There are arguments against (like memorizing is a pain). I have to memorize lyrics to 160 songs, so that's not a problem. In summary, if you want maximum song list flexibility AND a kick-*ss preset for each song, it's an effective solution. I do both and love using a non-linear foot switch system.