Today I tested Firmware Q9.0 installed on my Axe-Fx XL versus the Firmware 8.02 installed on my AX8, using seven random amp+speaker only presets (chosen from the 700+ Naked Amps TonePack).
Used same presets from each unit/matched exactly. Here are the soundclip results comparing them.
For each amp, the AX8 and FW 8.02 is first heard, and the XL is second heard, with same amp model and roughly same riff/lick. Guitar is through A/B box. Used both Fractal's SP/DIF output1s into DAW running Logic to record everything (no other processing).
The only preset adjustment I did was to set the SPKR COMP on the FW9 XL for each of the sevens amp's presest to a value of 5.0 (after some trial and error, based on how close it sounded to the AX8 FW 8.02 version to do that to me) and to raise the amp block LEVEL a little to compensate for any volume loss due to added SPKR compression.
What to raise the LEVEL by, did vary by amp -- trying to get the XL fader signal register same volume as the AX8 channel fader signal (showing averaging -12db) to avoid Mr. Fletcher Munson curve tricking my ears... Played and listened to everything at 92db loudness (it makes a difference than lower level which seems to blur the preset firmware tonal differences rather than exaggerate them).
To me, not surprisingly, the two firmwares do make the presets sound different EQ wise/--not exactly the same.
Thoughts? Do you prefer one over the other?
1. Hook 2b
2. Freidman Small Box
3. Vox AC15
4. Plexi 100 Jumped
5. Vibroverb AB
6. BlackFace Princeton Reverb
7. Vibroverb AB (again) -- there is a last/third amp clip here is NO SPKR Compression on the XL, just as example.
Interesting exercise!