I can understand the OP (and others) viewpoint. I had 6 or 8 of my favorite patches setup on my Standard and they were fantastic. I can't recall how many minutes or hours I may have put in to refining them, but I did not do much tweaking as updates came out. My II has already demanded more attention to get *my* sounds than my Standard did, but that may be because I was unintentionally following my old patch-building paradigm. There is, IMO, much more realism in the overall simulations, and I find myself chasing away the same gremlins I hunt in my real amps. Things like fizz and treble peaking caps now get more attention on the II from me. Big Kudos to Cliff for this groundbreaking realism. R/W Speakers and Mics that worked Gen I now don't tame (low pass) the natural amp harshness the same on Gen II - IMO. This is not really a problem since I just find another IR and Mic, but in my experience, the component interplay is *different". I really like the Gen II modeling and realism, including the swirl one of the Mods inferred was too subjective a term: they should stop by Aiken's Amp page and look at his discussion of swirl in the Glossary of Terms (
Aiken Amplification). So, depending on your experience and mindset, the II may seem harder or easier to get your sound(s) from. BTW, the presets did nothing for me personally and I had to build my patches from scratch: that's just me and my approach. Others have reported very different opinions: that's as it should be.
I don't know how my experience maps to others, and I really don't care. I'm a lower gain aficionado and seek that edge of breakup territory where lots of dynamic and other artifacts may be found. With a little open-minded perseverance, I have most of my patches now equaling and bettering my Standard's performance - not because the Standard was obsoleted by Gen II, but rather because I'm exploring the new modeling paradigm and using the improved tools available.
Hopefully most users will find their way and enjoy the Gen II boxes, but like I've seen over the last 4 years here, there will certainly be those for which the Axe II is not their cup of tea: so be it.
enjoy
boogie