went through this with a jmp owner. bmtp go from -6 to +6 and they match the same values on the axe. so +4 on the jmp = +4 on the axe
gain goes to +20 which equals +10 on the axe
You are right on Simeon, if you are comparing just JMP1 preamp to preamp with the Axe, it holds true.
What gets a little funky is - the power amp you are using with your actual JMP1 vs. the power amp in the Axe.
(This is going to sound obvious to some, but just something to keep in mind when dialing in a JMP1 in the Axe)
I use my actual JMP-1 running through the Marshall 100/100 power amp (which I believe it is meant to be paired with).
It's a bright/raspy power amp (maybe even described as a little scooped IMO).
The power amp modelled in the Axe is a little darker, which means +4 treble on each is going to sound a little different (IF you are used to hearing the Marshall 100/100 poweramp with the JMP1).
I find that I use more treble and presence in the Axe to try and counter that darkness.
Yes, I know I can (and I do) tweak power amp settings in the Axe....just pointing out that sometimes +4 (for example) doesn't result in the same tone....thus if you are using settings in the JMP1 manual, it may not sound exactly as they would have when run through the Marshall power amp (that seems to have been what the JMP1 was meant to be paired with).
I would love for Cliff to take my Marshall 100/100 and have that used to model the JMP1 within the Axe.
@FractalAudio - I'm local to you if you want to borrow it