Good question...
I can say that:
- I have no regrets for having invested in the Axe-FX II.
- I am surprised at how many people have sold their lot of tube-amps, etc. for the Axe-FX II.
- (Personally, I'd rather (and do) own both, (tube-amps and an Axe-FX II) but I think some users intend to have their amps coexist with the Axe-FX II, just to find their (valuable) amps collecting dust - LOL!
- Along with my first reel-to-reel Tascam/Teac 40-4 Multi-Track Tape Recorder (yup...flying the "old-guy flag" with that admission!) no other piece of gear has gotten me/forced me to want to learn more about getting the most from the gear itself (in the case of my Teac/Tascam 40-4 MTD, I learned about engineering, mixing, mixer-routing, mics & mic-techniques, effects, etc.) and now with the Axe-FX II, I find myself learning about tube-amp design, (from a component level practically) about the strengths and weaknesses of various amps, the importance of an amp's power-section, the importance of the cab design and speaker-usage, (a recent and huge eye-opener!) as well as the newer IR-technology, and it's role in being a "virtual cab")etc, etc, etc! Sure I might've read about some of these things, but owning said gear and wanting to really know how to use it, FORCES me (and frankly, I'm the type who needs such a "kick-in-the-arse" once in a while - LOL!) and probably others to really learn/know my/their stuff!
- I think in the bigger picture, Cliff/Fractal are still a small drop in a bigger (but shrinking - LOL!) bucket, but make no mistake, they are DEFINITELY turning some heads and getting the attention of of some major-players and manufacturers!
- The Axe-FX II is NOT perfect, but NOTHING EVER IS, and it sure keeps getting better all the time, thanks to Cliff's/Fractal's willingness to listen to their customer-base, and their continuing and tireless deveopment/support/firmware-updates!
These are my 2-pennies...
Bill