Jason Scott
Fractal Fanatic
Its not a good test i can i tell you. It has none of the qualities an amp can be judged by, the stuff that makes an amp stand out do not exist in your examples. Again- Dynamic playing and dynamic presentation. Its just not there. Dont blame me for that. Make some examples of dynamic playing on clean tones, in breakup tones, let the player play dynamically and dont have it so compressed. Thats when you can judge the quality of the amp. Im sorry, but this is not on me.
Oh, so you can easily tell the difference between a modeler and an amp so long as the samples adhere to some strict list of requirements you have regarding the type of tone that must be recorded for the test? Look, there are plenty of high gain blind tests on YouTube where the tone is distorted to the high heavens and any number of people can hear the difference on any given day with respect to other modelers and amps, even when listening to a low bitrate sample, so spare me the fallacious reasoning, okay?