From my end, I'm a still a little confused on the whole amp "resetting after FW update" scenario.
I'm only using AustinBuddy's presets in this discussion as a point of reference - it could be any presets. I happen to like AB's presets, so I used this as a milestone that many may be familiar with. It could just as easily be the stock presets in the AxeFx.
I'm not a newbie; been round since the original AxeFx, and this is my 3rd or 4th unit. I've read the Manual, the wiki, and follow the Forum regularly. I'm just having trouble wrapping my pea-brain around some of the block resetting concepts; maybe I'm just attention-deficit or something:
1. If the Amp blocks are reset in all of my AustinBuddy presets, do I then loose all of AB's amp settings settings? In other words, will they all be reset back to a "Factory Default" setting? Straight-up 5's all the way across, for lack of a better description?
2. If I do reset all the amp block in all my Austin Buddy presets, I presume this will need to be for every Scene, in every Amp block, individually?
3. Also, if I reset all of the Amp blocks in all of my AB presets, do I then need to reload all of the presets, to get back to "near" the intent of the original AB settings, or am I just then setting everything back to the "incorrect" Amp block settings again by doing this?
4. I "think" my best option, to get the most of the AxeFx FW upgrades, and my AB presets, I should reset every amp block, in every scene, and save each preset, then reload all of the original AB presets - is this the optimal way to go about this, or should I just not reset the amps? What am I "missing", if I don't reset the amps?
5. As I understand it, running a "Refresh" after new FW " in Axe-Edit III is not necessarily changing any preset settings, or resetting any blocks - it's only refreshing the data in Axe-Edit, so it is displayed properly (correct?).
6. Would I be better off to just do a total factory reset of "everything", reset my basic/global settings, then reload my AustinBuddy presets, to save time?
These aren't intended to be esoteric questions, or circular reasoning - I really don't know, and want to boil it down to something I can grasp. I want to get the "best", most accurate tone I can, and have been very happy with AB's presets; I also want to keep my AxeFx as current as possible. I'm just a little confused on the best way to go about resetting the Amp blocks, and what to do with my presets after resetting.
1 - in short, yes. you lose the settings if you reset an amp block. i think the "soft reset" isn't the same anymore due to the recent addition of authentic controls, since that now defaults basic controls like bass, mid, treb etc.
2 - every channel of the amp block used would need to be reset if you "want to reset all amp blocks."
3 - if you reset the amp blocks, then reload the old preset data, it will be as if you didn't reset the amp block. it's because you reloaded the old data.
4 - question is... why would you do this? that seems like so much work. if you load FW 5 and the preset sounds good, then it sounds good. i personally would think it's ultimately the preset creator's "responsibility" (?) to update presets for future firmware. i don't buy presets, so i don't know much about it, but if i sold presets, i personally would not guarantee or make it seem like the preset you buy today will work with all future firmwares, without revisions either from the user or myself (creator).
you CAN do what you mentioned here, but why do you have to do them for all? i would just save duplicate copies of the presets i use, reset the amp blocks, experiment, and then use whatever sounds better.
for example, for my main preset, with 5.02, i noticed my clean amp was too bassy, my high gain amp needed more bass. i just adjusted those things, and i sound great again. i didn't reset, i just adjusted what i heard.
i think some people are reacting a bit drastically about all of this. if you load the new firmware and your presets sound good, then you're done. if something sounds wrong, just adjust that.
this firmware in particular mentions that it forces certain parameters to new values, something most firmware does NOT do. so you definitely get the new features of the firmware with 5.xx. it all depends on what actually has changed and if there are brand new parameters.
5 - Refresh after FW is in Axe-Edit only and just synchronizes the computer with the Axe.
6 - again, resetting or doing anything else is pointless if you just load the old settings right back on. they are the old settings.
--
again. load the new firmware. if you hear something wrong, fix it. if you don't, then you're done. it's very simple.