I have 2 CLRs and, with experimentation, I've found an amp/cab combo that is beyond anything I ever had with a real cab and head and sounds every bit as convincing as an amp blaring out behind you, rather than a mic'd cab. For me, I LIKE that it sounds like a cab and amp to me and, (and this is contentious), I'm not worried about what the audience hears. Sound guy will take care of that. I just need it to sound and feel good to ME, so I can play my best.
The sounds are in there, for sure... just need to persevere.
I need to rebuild my main patch on the AX8 (Axe II is now gone), but when I do, I'd be happy to post it if you want to try it out. At the end of the day though, you have to do what's right for you.
Good luck dude!
Sukh