Yamaha Revstar 2 Standard - A real winner.

Okay - just talked to Musician's Friend. The guy there was really helpful. He said that the best discount he can give me is a 10% refund of purchase price. List is $1,999. I got $300 off, so they would refund me $169. Not what I was hoping for, but better than nothing. I have until March 25th to return it, so I have some time to make a decision. He told me to give Yamaha a call. He said that, in his experience, Yamaha was very helpful when it comes to warranty issues and that it's worth talking to them before I do anything. He also confirmed that if I do any sort of repair I will not longer be able to return the guitar to Musician's Friend. The Yamaha warranty center for guitars doesn't open until Monday morning, so I'm just going to sit tight until I can talk to Yamaha on Monday. I have options here, so I'm not screwed. Worst case I'll get my money back. Or I can just fix the damn thing and get $169 back. Or maybe Yamaha will "wow" me and do something exceptional under warranty. Feeling a lot better after confirming that I have reasonable options. I'll keep y'all posted.

If you like it, take the $169 and fix it, since it’s an easy fix. Unless you’ve gone sour on the guitar. If so, send it back.
 
If you like it, take the $169 and fix it, since it’s an easy fix. Unless you’ve gone sour on the guitar. If so, send it back.
This ^^^, and perhaps the OP should change the name of the thread to "Yamaha Revstar- a real bummer.":tearsofjoy:
It is a bit of a strange arrangement for the high end model to have the same hardware and electrics as the cheap one but I suppose PRS started this with the S2 having the SE budget stuff fitted.
 
I was eyeing a Professional too, but given their same hardware and electronics, especially tuners and pickups, I'll be happy with my Standard.

While the tuners are ok, I'd have expected a branded version for the Pro. And while pickups are made to Yamaha spec, a Pro version shouldn't say G&B on the pup plate.
Love the fretwork though!

It's my 3rd Yamaha, over 30 years after I bought my first two. One of which was this '89 Image Custom. Made in Taiwan it cost more than a Les Paul StudioLite in the day. I bought it overseas, but it was about the equivalent of $1,600-1,800 today. So twice the Standard, and almost Pro pricing.
But no-compromise features:
  • Brazilian Rosewood fingerboard
  • Immaculate fit, finish, fretwork
  • 'Yamaha Japan' LOCKING tuners (but really Gotoh I think)
  • Yamaha pickups (don't know if they outsourced back then, but these were highly proprietary active/passive tech, and sound amazing)
  • Carved, flame top
  • Abalone inlays (not abalam)

Wish the Revstar Standards and Pros would live up to this...

XQ4iICB.jpg
rWt4TtF.jpg

lar9Wi1.jpg
sPYn4U1.jpg
Some models are good but don't be too quick. Look at that horrendous 12th fret inlay filler, weird actives and odd trem with no support for parts.
 
170 bucks in your pocket for a quick fix to plug a hole under the pick up. Good god, fix it and keep it.

I've done much worse when building a partscaster for myself. Snapped screws, plugged holes. If it can't be seen, then take that 170 bucks and enjoy the guitar.
 
Some models are good but don't be too quick. Look at that horrendous 12th fret inlay filler, weird actives and odd trem with no support for parts.
You know what they say about opinions....

It may not meet your exacting, sometimes seemingly unattainable standards, but it is possible for a guitar to be great without being perfect in your eyes.
 
You know what they say about opinions....

It may not meet your exacting, sometimes seemingly unattainable standards, but it is possible for a guitar to be great without being perfect in your eyes.
I am not talking about opinions , those inlays and the things I mentioned are objectively bad but It can still be a great sounding and playing guitar. I am commenting about decisions made at Yamaha more than anything here. Yamaha have a long history of producing great product that they just drop and end support faster than you can say "next".
 
You know what they say about opinions....

It may not meet your exacting, sometimes seemingly unattainable standards, but it is possible for a guitar to be great without being perfect in your eyes.
Another thing to take in to consideration is when you look at an R9 Les Paul there is a lot of crappy elements in the way it is built and a few design points that are far less than functional but nobody would deny it is a phenomenal musical instrument me included.
 
170 bucks in your pocket for a quick fix to plug a hole under the pick up. Good god, fix it and keep it.

I've done much worse when building a partscaster for myself. Snapped screws, plugged holes. If it can't be seen, then take that 170 bucks and enjoy the guitar.
I wouldn't have a problem just fixing the damn thing but Yamaha told me that if I fix it myself I will void the warranty. To keep the warranty I would have to take it to a Yamaha warranty service center, which is an hour each way, plus leaving it there for a week (or a month). I'm waiting for my regular Musician's Friend rep to come back to work tomorrow (he's off Sunday and Monday) to see if he can give me a bigger refund. It will cost them a whole lot more than $169 to deal with a factory defect guitar. If $169 is all they'll offer then I am sending it back. Taking it to the warranty repair center is too much hassle and I'm not going to pay a premium for a new guitar just to void the warranty a month after I get it. That is unless MF makes it worth it to me. We'll see what happens.
 
So...Iscottk's disappointment aside, I played a couple more of these the other day and was very impressed. Again.

But...I don't feel like I need one. I think the GAS for one may have just disappeared.
 
So...Iscottk's disappointment aside, I played a couple more of these the other day and was very impressed. Again.

But...I don't feel like I need one. I think the GAS for one may have just disappeared.
But for the stripped wood screw, I really like my guitar. So I agree with you. These are good guitars, especially for the money.

The hassle is certainly a downer, but a stripped screw could happen on any production guitar. And I've had a worse problem on a custom build with a young builder who used the wrong sealer on the wood, so that the nitro finish started to bubble because the nitro didn't adhere properly. That guitar seemed to be cursed (and I'm only half joking). It took 3.5 years from payment to receipt after the refinish to correct the nitro problem. Then it got stolen when someone sneaked into my house while I was asleep under the influence of narcotics because of pain from passing a kidney stone. They walked right by my head, no more than 2 feet away, to steal the guitar and my wife's purse. They stole our car, which we eventually got back with only a few cigarette burns and the reek of stale beer. The guitar was never found. Probably in some drug dealers living room.

Shit happens. Roll with the punches, I say. I don't have any rockets headed towards my house, and I've got food and a heater keeping my family warm. Life is good. :)
 
But for the stripped wood screw, I really like my guitar. So I agree with you. These are good guitars, especially for the money.

The hassle is certainly a downer, but a stripped screw could happen on any production guitar. And I've had a worse problem on a custom build with a young builder who used the wrong sealer on the wood, so that the nitro finish started to bubble because the nitro didn't adhere properly. That guitar seemed to be cursed (and I'm only half joking). It took 3.5 years from payment to receipt after the refinish to correct the nitro problem. Then it got stolen when someone sneaked into my house while I was asleep under the influence of narcotics because of pain from passing a kidney stone. They walked right by my head, no more than 2 feet away, to steal the guitar and my wife's purse. They stole our car, which we eventually got back with only a few cigarette burns and the reek of stale beer. The guitar was never found. Probably in some drug dealers living room.

Shit happens. Roll with the punches, I say. I don't have any rockets headed towards my house, and I've got food and a heater keeping my family warm. Life is good. :)

That story is insane. And that's a great outlook. I like it.

They are very good guitars, as far as I can tell. And, yes, sometime sh*t happens. The ones I've played have been loud and lively and resonant....just very nice. They just didn't impress me as much as other guitars the shop had (in this case, a couple Heritage H-150s), which I don't feel like paying for right now given that I really like my Les Paul and my 594....so, those all kind of fit into a niche that I've already filled. Given a higher guitar budget, I'd have a couple of them just because of the colors.

But...the GAS/FOMO/whatever kind of went away. At least for now.

If it were my guitar that did that, I'd just fix it. But, I generally don't value warranties all that much when it's something I'm not actively prevented from fixing myself. I probably would have filled it as soon as I saw it without even asking if there was another option. But...I also replaced all the electronics in my PRS S2 and had the holes reamed for American-spec pots before it was a week old. That probably voided the warranty that I didn't even think about. But...I'm also confident that the brick & mortar shop I bought it from and probably PRS themselves would take care of me if I needed them to.
 
170 bucks in your pocket for a quick fix to plug a hole under the pick up. Good god, fix it and keep it.

I've done much worse when building a partscaster for myself. Snapped screws, plugged holes. If it can't be seen, then take that 170 bucks and enjoy the guitar.

Easy fix and a good discount. I bought a PRS SE 245 last year. Headstock got dinged pretty good in shipment. Reverb refunded me $200, I don’t even notice the ding, and I love the guitar, and it came in at $400 total.
 
Back
Top Bottom