skydog
Experienced
Exactly. This week (while waiting for any news about the FC12), I’m experimenting with a new set-up for a special night on 12/29. A 50W Dumble clone, together with a Dumbleator clone, in combination with the Axe FX III effects, and a Dawner Prince Boonar (because the Echorec currently isn’t cooperating). Spooky cool tone.I agree neither FRFR nor ears replicates the 3D sonic space of a guitar cabinet onstage. Whether or not that's important is a matter of opinion.
Guitar cabs sound different everywhere you stand--too bright here, too muddy there, sweet spot somewhere, but who stands in one place the whole show ? If you love the sound of walking over to the side of your amp and hearing a completely different tone than standing right in front, I agree, FRFR and ears will NOT capture that experience.
Personally, I greatly prefer getting the sound onstage to be as consistent as possible. I'm using Axe III with FRFR or ears right now, but for years before that, I used a tube amp and mic'd cabined into ear monitors. And like most of us, for many years before that, I just cranked up a guitar cab to hear myself. Personally, I MUCH preferred the consistent direct sound of a well-placed microphone on my cabinet vs. the real "cab in the room." And I prefer the Axe III into FRFR or ears vs. the same rig out to a power amp and guitar cab.
But not everyone will agree on that--all good. Find a rig that makes ya happy, and play
That’s next weekend’s rig.