Danny Danzi
Power User
Well, yes you are right and I agree with you. In my band, we have our own system and sound guy to run it, and he does run stereo. Our rooms are not giant, and in most cases are smaller clubs or something like a wedding or a corporate party. If we are doing something funk or straight rock like a 70's disco song, Chilli Peppers or something like The Killers or AC/DC or whatever... then I'm 100% with you. I keep it pretty basic and "narrow" and even dry for probably 90% of what I do.
But I do play a number of songs where there is something to be gained for the audience from that special effect. More ambient spacey sounds for an extended intro, or something like a U2 or Pink Floyd or whatever. I have gone out onto the floor, and it makes a big difference in the feel of some material when you have that width, or the effect of 2 guitars going on, or some ping pong or whatever. As a 3 piece, tightness, sonic control, and shape are everything to us.
Have you ever seen Kings X live? Man, Ty Tabor runs this insane W/D/W guitar rig, and his sound is just massive like nothing I have ever heard. It's literally one of the best things I've ever heard in my life (it was at a small club in Sacramento that I saw them, years ago, and it left me with an impression that will never die. I was totally sober too for the record.) I've seen the same thing with other local artists like Mike Gregory (an ex Nashville studio guy I used to know who is a MONSTER player) and Frank Hannon (Tesla guitar player, local Sac guy who does whup-ass 70's rock cover gigs with his side project.) Those guys all run stereo setups, and I'm telling you, their's is the sound I chase.
I'm a huge Satriani Fan. I've seen him in area's (Concord Pavilion, Arco Arena) and at medium clubs like The Filmore and Casino's in Reno. I've even seen him at Guitar Center doing a clinic. He runs a stereo rig, but it's not wide. It's right down the center and in your face, like you speak of. I think it can be done both ways. I do think getting the sound right in a big stereo field can be much harder to accomplish, and there is a ton of merit to what you are talking about. But when I have heard it done right... to me there is nothing like it. Material choice is a huge factor I think.
I am curious to check out that Edison device... you caught my interest with that.
No doubt, stereo is definitely way cooler! Like I say, for my bigger shows in Europe, we run that stuff and you'll usually find me with at the least, 4 Marshall cabs at any given time. For the right room and situation, it's awesome. Heck, even for the wrong room, it's still awesome. I actually miss my stereo feed for some of the smaller rooms I deal with in my cover band. But the difference there is, when I go overseas and do the DD original project, I got guys that handle all that. LOL! When I do the cover thing, it's me and my girl lugging all the gear. LOL! So we want as little gear moving as possible. My stripped down show is one Marshall slant cab with 25 watt greenback's, my MFC, two purple mission control pedals, and a 5 space rack with my power conditioner, wireless, AxeFx and a power amp.
Yeah the Edison is a neat little box. It just enhances anything that is in stereo....giving it an almost 3-D effect. Cool, but you have to be careful with it.