Not use drive blocks? Hawg warsh!
I'll use anything and everything in this little black box to achieve my desired tone(s). That's what it's all there for, isn't it?
If I need it, I'll use it. If I don't, I won't, but a blanket suggestion that drives aren't needed at all is just silly. I mainly create and use high gain patches, *extreme* high gain in some cases (think heavily over driven ADA MP1 for 80's style tones) so drive blocks are nearly a requirement for most amps in order to get the effect I want.
My apologies if my comment came across as a blanket statement. It was meant to be a personal opinion on the use of the drive section.
I owned an MP1 for a long time. TWO in fact. Still kinda miss it sometimes. It had a GREAT chorus effect! I first used it with a power amp then I drove the power amp section of a regular amp with it. To say that a drive block is NECESSARY to get sounds similar to the MP1 is, to use your words, Hawg Wash. It can easily be achieved with just the distortion available in many of the amp blocks alone! I can fully appreciate the need outside the AXE FX to use a drive in conjunction with a mid gained amp to get that tone. If one wants to replicate THAT in the Axe, by all means do so! It certainly is fun to mimic real life setups, but that misses my point. There is plenty of gain to be had in the amp blocks alone as to negate the need for more distortion via a drive block.
While I respect your opinion, I strongly disagree. Most people don't use the drive block simply for the extra gain, they do it for the tone that the drive pedal adds. In fact, 95% of the time I use the 808 I leave the gain around 1-10 MAX. I like the saturation and bite it adds to the tone, which would be IMPOSSIBLE to dial in with just the amp block. Especially considering each drive pedal has its own unique sound.
I can totally understand the desire to use the drive pedal as an extra bit of eq or touch of grit, whatever. I firmly believe however that these necessities are waaayyy more marketing hocus pocus and cultural voodoo than actual needs and requirements to achieving a useful tone. The standard High, Mid, Low controls have always been more than enough EQ. Need more High? Turn up the friggen knob labeled High!! Lets face it, the only people who care about this level of minutia are us guitar players! The reality is that it all gets mostly lost within the context of a band and definitely if there are two guitars! Do we really need to have that insignificant, c**t-hair amount of whatever that a drive is going to give an already distorted amp? We can't seem to play a f**king note on the guitar unless we have that extra 2% of eq. Seriously?? :lol My money says no. But here again.....it's purely my opinion and I will absolutely not begrudge anyone else the pleasure they get from pursuing their own tone endeavors.
Yeah, I'm with Shredder3386. I use drives with minimal gain and very high level for how they interact with the amp, rather than the additional gain. Playing modern metal, you really need that reverse-mid-scoop and super-hot signal hitting the front of the amp.
With the Axe you could no doubt do similar with GEQ and things, but it just works with an 808 or a BB or so on... that's the way you hit a real 5150. The natural EQ of the drives is awesomely suited to the front end of an amp.
See my last comment for most of my opinion. I'll just say again that I feel there is more than plenty of gain on tap with the amps in the Axe (and many on "real" amps for that matter) as to warrant the use of a drive as a moot point. My "real" amps that get the most use are an early 5150 and a Marshall DSL2000. I play(ed) in all-original and cover metal bands I've personally never felt the need to push those amps with a drive pedal and I HAVE tried it on several occasions. I guess I carry over that tradition or personal technique inside the Axe as well.
Hell, I could be the weird one in all of this.
I guess I'm entrenched in the camp that finds any "extra stuff" to just get in the way. I'm a less-is-more, plug-in-and-go-for-it kind of player these days.
Hey....great discussion!!! Do I need to repeat that this is my opinion?