Yes, I cherry picked this one line, but I have to ask, and I assure you I don't mean this in a snarky or condescending way, but just how golden -are- your ears?
I've taken fairly good care of mine and I can hear pretty minor differences between real amps using the same speaker(s). And re the AxeIII, sure, it can be said they're not -exactly- the same (real amp/speakers vs AxeIII through power amp [tube or solid state] and traditional guitar speakers).
But I've most definitely been able to get nearly indistinguishable tones
w/AxeIII-PA-Guitar Speakers in comparison to my real amps...through the same speakers.
I say nearly indistinguishable, because they're so close, in a blind test, one can't pick one over the other. I've done this multiple times with multiple friends/guitarists. Different people, same results...every time.
Granted, this is with the most recent AxeIII updates (anytime after the second version of Cygnus came out), but it definitely has evolved to the level of sameness that truly requires hearing ability far beyond what most have to distinguish differences.
So it's kind of baffling to read someone say it's not even close. That's almost laughable (honestly ... no offense intended). I can't even say I think mine is only a subjective opinion. I believe it's clearly -become- an observable objective opinion throughout the guitar community. Perfect? No, but comes up microscopically short....at worst.
Of course, not everyone likes everything, but not even close......really???????
Not trying to be snarky? But saying my opinion is laughable?
But saying yours is not a subjective opinion?
What is anyone’s opinion regarding tone if not subjective?
I stand by my “not even close”
based on my 42 years as a tone obsessed musician and guitar/amp collector,
It’s ok I’m used to the amp sim cultists
That need to justify the purchase
Frankly I don’t have to deal with whole buyers remorse thing
I’ve made a good living in the industry and have no qualms debating why,
I wonder why myself sometimes now at 60 years old
But I can buy whatever I want and if I don’t like it it goes into an adjoining area for future evaluation or as part of the collection
But the point is simple
There’s the real thing Marshall, Friedman, Dumble whatever
And then there is the attempt to copy the real thing
AxeFx, line 6, Strymon whatever
And the real thing sounds and feels a certain way that is obviously pleasing enough that companies like fractal said
Hey let’s copy that!
All I can tell you is using my golden (y)ears
Is when I plug into my IIc+ and right next to it is high end latest updated
Axe3-toslink/spdif into one of my Apollo X8s and then into a pair of $3000 a piece Genelec 8341
All crystal clear digital connection with very top shelf converters
They don’t sound the same, not even close
Does the axe sound good? That would be subjective
But does it sound like that amp? No!
And the same for every amp I’ve tried simply comparing what Fractal says it’s supposed to be and what the real amps sound like
Roland chorus, Vox AC
Those cleans and break ups are close
Super high fractal gain sounds good but not like my SLO 100
I don’t care what the GUI says
I like Leon Todd’s channel and he as you know does a lot with the fractal products
But every time he dials in
“That sound” which sound great, it always sounds kinda the same heavy distortion with stereo Fx processing
And until he adds the stereo shimmering FX it doesn’t really sound that great just distorted
Similar to a Marshall but not enough to replace my jvm410
So why would I plug-in live to a ehh emulation of an amp I own
Doesn't seem logical to me
And I have zero reason to pretend it does
Do you really think when you open all those fractal tabs in Axe Edit and chose a different valve or clipping diode
That they managed to capture the actual properties of said elements
And there’s dozens and dozens of these elements
Now that’s laughable
Way too much goes into building an amp from the physical transformer, voltage, manufacturer to the chipset type like on a jcm900, valves,valve type and manufacturer, both power and pre-amp, valve sockets, hand wired or ICB or both
The pots and caps ect..
Do you really think fractal has all that figured out so they can emulate all on those amps?
Impossible