Even though I'd done my research prior to my purchase, this was still weird for me to wrap my head around, even though I'm primarily a studio/live guitarist, being USED to those sounds was one thing, not going through the gymnastics of dialing in my amp sound in order to get the sound I wanted when mic'd, that was another thing entirely.Apples and oranges. The Axe-Fx plus CLR is a loud version of what you would hear in the control room AND what the audience would hear from a mic'd amp. If you want traditional guitar cab tone then use a power amp and traditional cab.
This is modeling 101. You guys should know this by now.
I started out with my Axe-FX (a whopping month or so ago) as a replacement for my effects and for studio use. Over the space of about, maybe a week I said 'to hell with that', picked up a QSC K12 and have happily gone through several gigs and a slew of studio hours without looking back.
It IS a bit of a different paradigm, but once you wrap your head around it life changes considerably for the better.
The other guitarists I play with regularly are pissed.