Fender Princeton Reverb Tone Master Thoughts

bleujazz3

Axe-Master
Just curious as to what your thoughts are regards this recent Fender offering...was impressed by the Sweetwater demo video, but have not considered taking the plunge...thoughts, pros, cons, value for the money, tone, etc?
 
I’d pony up for the tube version were it me. Not a lot to care for, and it’ll probably sound better.
So I don’t know or care to do the solid state replica thing. But that’s just me. I would get to a shop and hear both if I was so inclined. Maybe it’s okay?
P.S. resale value if you decide to part with it, don’t know….but maybe the tube version will hold more value?
 
I will know for certain Monday, but I expect the FR-12 is a class D frfr solution .. with the classic Fender TMB tone stack in front. I don't think their modeling platform is ready just yet. 😉👍

But as for your question.. I would buy an old deluxe or Princeton. And make the FAS sound like that. Then play both at the same time.
 
I’d pony up for the tube version were it me. Not a lot to care for, and it’ll probably sound better.
So I don’t know or care to do the solid state replica thing. But that’s just me. I would get to a shop and hear both if I was so inclined. Maybe it’s okay?
P.S. resale value if you decide to part with it, don’t know….but maybe the tube version will hold more value?
Was wondering if the solid-state/hybrid thing is approaching equal tone with tube amps. Seems like the solid-state price is almost comparable to a tube Princeton, perhaps falling a couple hundred shy.

Possibly next week when visiting my local shop; they have several ToneMaster amps in stock. The Deluxe Reverb ToneMaster sounded somewhat muffled, as if the presence knob (not that there was one) was turned way down. Have heard good things about the Princeton Reverb ToneMaster (video clips represent well).

A vintage PR would def hold its value compared to something more recent. Even a used PR reissue from the 90s would do as well. Not sure I'd wish to invest in something with tubes again, what for the maintenance and regular tube replacements as added expenses...
 
I will know for certain Monday, but I expect the FR-12 is a class D frfr solution .. with the classic Fender TMB tone stack in front. I don't think their modeling platform is ready just yet. 😉👍

But as for your question.. I would buy an old deluxe or Princeton. And make the FAS sound like that. Then play both at the same time.
Perhaps the smart route would be recreate the PR as a FM9 user preset, with necessary effects for desired sound/tone (subjective, of course). An alternative is to test-drive the FR-12 with my FM9, and see if this is a viable option for gigs, compared to my current FRFR home rig. I think I've got extra storage space, will need to check the FR-12 dimensions to be sure...

EDIT: Noted slight size differential with the FR-10 and FR-12. Might wish to stick with the smaller speaker in order to avoid size/weight issues. My storage space will accommodate either one, but the smaller FR-10 might be the ticket...
 
Last edited:
I bet if you walk in to the dealer, have them have the tm next to current gen princeton and have them a/b while you cant see you wont really know which is which. Confirmation bias is a very real thing.

Buy a used one and let someone else take the depreciation hit.
 
Was wondering if the solid-state/hybrid thing is approaching equal tone with tube amps. Seems like the solid-state price is almost comparable to a tube Princeton, perhaps falling a couple hundred shy.

Possibly next week when visiting my local shop; they have several ToneMaster amps in stock. The Deluxe Reverb ToneMaster sounded somewhat muffled, as if the presence knob (not that there was one) was turned way down. Have heard good things about the Princeton Reverb ToneMaster (video clips represent well).

A vintage PR would def hold its value compared to something more recent. Even a used PR reissue from the 90s would do as well. Not sure I'd wish to invest in something with tubes again, what for the maintenance and regular tube replacements as added expenses...
The Princeton is a baby amp as far as maintenance goes. :)
 
I bet if you walk in to the dealer, have them have the tm next to current gen princeton and have them a/b while you cant see you wont really know which is which. Confirmation bias is a very real thing.

Buy a used one and let someone else take the depreciation hit.
That confirms my next thought. What with the recent hype of the Tone Master series it makes good sense to wait until used ToneMasters begin showing up in local shops.

From what I hear regards the FR-10/12s, there is noticeable noise floor compared to my current FRFRs. Only one YT reviewer took the time to compare noise floor volumes with nothing put through the cabinets. @WKSmith might wish to make note of this. Also, the FR-10/12 sounds nothing like my current FRFR (QSC CP8s). More distant, lacking clarity compared to clean/clear, quality FRFR. According to the review, some compared this as to more "amp-like" or "amp-in-the-room" sound/tone than the sound/tone of quality FRFRs.

Yet, the Princeton Reverb ToneMaster does not exhibit the noise floor that the FR-10/12s do. The workaround for the ToneMaster Pro (the FR-12 was plugged into) was to uncheck the AUX and Bluetooth boxes while in OS Mixer mode. Cannot project what would happen with additional modelers, but can safely say that Fender will need to update its firmware so as to reflect an improved noise floor than currently.
 
Last edited:
The Princeton is a baby amp as far as maintenance goes. :)
I'm not sure I can confirm what you say; my feeling is that every tube amp will need regular tube swaps as often as necessary. It's an inescapable fact, even my beloved Brunetti Singleman 30W Combo needed a tube swap at least once during the 3-year timeframe the amp was part of my home music room. Had the amp been vintage, I might expect additional maintenance due to age, wear and tear, etc.

That might be a good reason for my holding back on investing in a vintage piece. Will be able to check out the PR ToneMaster next weekend. I'm not planning on ordering/buying anything of significant cost until perhaps after tax refunds arrive next year. I'm officially over the hill at age 65 this year and need to see what taxes will do next year before agreeing to any big-ticket purchases.

What @Budda said about letting someone else take the depreciation hit makes good sense as well.
 
I'm not sure I can confirm what you say; my feeling is that every tube amp will need regular tube swaps as often as necessary. It's an inescapable fact, even my beloved Brunetti Singleman 30W Combo needed a tube swap at least once during the 3-year timeframe the amp was part of my home music room. Had the amp been vintage, I might expect additional maintenance due to age, wear and tear, etc.

That might be a good reason for my holding back on investing in a vintage piece. Will be able to check out the PR ToneMaster next weekend. I'm not planning on ordering/buying anything of significant cost until perhaps after tax refunds arrive next year. I'm officially over the hill at age 65 this year and need to see what taxes will do next year before agreeing to any big-ticket purchases.

What @Budda said about letting someone else take the depreciation hit makes good sense as well.
I get it. I’m just saying the Princeton circuit is one of their simplest circuits...not many tubes.
It’s funny, I‘ve had several Fenders and didn’t have a lot of issues with them other than changing a tube every 5 or 10 years that was always easier than de-soldering op amps in a solid state amp. :)
 
I get it. I’m just saying the Princeton circuit is one of their simplest circuits...not many tubes.
It’s funny, I‘ve had several Fenders and didn’t have a lot of issues with them other than changing a tube every 5 or 10 years that was always easier than de-soldering op amps in a solid state amp. :)
If Princetons are self-biasing amps (have forgotten the correct phrase) like my Blues Deluxe was, it might be well worth looking into a used PR Reissue. I used to own a SuperChamp X2 that was tube and a 10" speaker, but even that had a noise floor that was noticeable. (Yeah, I'm that guy who doesn't dig ambient noise in the home music room.)

It was noted in several YT vids that the Princeton ToneMaster has almost zero noise floor; the reason for my interest in this. I'd be interested to learn what type of warranty Fender offers. Used amps, you run the risk of all sorts of issues that might crop up after a year. Might be nice if the warranty were transferable, but how often does that happen?

Care to hear something typical? The guy I sold my Brunetti to won't sell the amp back to me, because he got it for an incredible price, and is holding onto the amp because it's a wonderful clean platform for effects. I'd really like to bug the heck out of the guy until he relinquishes, but he's one of my luthier contacts who does tech work for a great price. Rock & a hard place. The Brunetti sale was less than a new PR ToneMaster. What's the kicker? The guy suggested I buy a Boss Katana and get over it. Oh, wah!
 
Last edited:
Just curious as to what your thoughts are regards this recent Fender offering...was impressed by the Sweetwater demo video, but have not considered taking the plunge...thoughts, pros, cons, value for the money, tone, etc?
I have several friends who I play with that have purchased the Princeton or Deluxe version, and I have yet to hear one sound like the tube version of the same amp.

Perhaps it’s because they haven’t broken in the speaker, or they assumed the same knob positions would yield the same sound, but whatever it is, they’ve sounded… sterile? I’ve been disappointed because I love the sound of a good Deluxe or Princeton at 6 on the volume.

I’ve mentioned it before, but I have a Tone King Imperial Mk II, which is a killer good version of a Blackface Deluxe on its rhythm channel and somewhere between a Bassman and a Tweed on the lead channel. I’ve been working on a preset to replicate its sound for a couple years, slowly dialing in the sound and using increasingly deeper parameters as I fine tune, but it’s getting closer and closer each time. And, I kind of feel bad for people who want to do similar things with modelers or digital amps that lack the breadth and depth of the Fractals.

Perhaps they’ll end up here, or they’ll swear off digital, or they’ll double-down and insist that it can’t get any better than what they have. Like so many others have found, having the options and flexibility are great things when we’re chasing a sound.
 
Last edited:
I have several friends who I play with that have purchased the Princeton or Deluxe version, and I have yet to hear one sound like the tube version of the same amp.

Perhaps it’s because they haven’t broken in the speaker, or they assumed the same knob positions would yield the same sound, but whatever it is, they’ve sounded… sterile? I’ve been disappointed because I love the sound of a good Deluxe or Princeton at 6 on the volume.
When one first hears the ToneMaster series, you'd be hard-pressed to say that they sound anything like the tube equivalent. Yet, because this is what YT offers, it served as a basis for my interest. It might be the speaker. I think I've got a 30Hz audio file I can pipe through the speaker for about 8 hours a couple days in a row. (It helped with a Neodymium speaker I had purchased).

Check this out:



How you feel now? It may be something that needs additional research with humbucker-equipped guitars. Not so much worried about single coils, but Fender builds these also for their products, which I no gots.
 
Last edited:
When one first hears the ToneMaster series, you'd be hard-pressed to say that they sound anything like the tube equivalent. Yet, because this is what YT offers, it served as a basis for my interest.

Check this out:



How you feel now?

Yet, if you have heard them in the room with the tube versions there’s a warmth missing. Again, it might be the speaker needs to be broken in, but I haven’t been impressed.
 
Yet, if you have heard them in the room with the tube versions there’s a warmth missing. Again, it might be the speaker needs to be broken in, but I haven’t been impressed.
Interesting. The YT vids of the Deluxe I've viewed seem like the presence if turned way down, almost a muffled warmth. I'll check both of these soon at my local store. I think they've got the ToneMaster series as demo models and see if what you say is right about the speaker being fresh off the boat...
 
YouTube videos are a horrible way to judge (yet we all keep doing it). If you're making judgments off a YouTube video, you really need to take a breath and realize that until you actually play through both, you have no idea.

You can play through one amp on one day and love it, then play through another on a different day and love that too. Then play them back to back and wonder how you even liked one or the other.

You may not be able to tell a difference when listening to someone else playing them, but it may be a huge difference when playing them yourself. At that point you have to ask who you're trying to please. To be fair, the audience will be fine either way, so we are mostly all trying to be as happy as we can with our own tones.

So play them yourself. That's the only way you'll know which you prefer.
 
Yet, if you have heard them in the room with the tube versions there’s a warmth missing. Again, it might be the speaker needs to be broken in, but I haven’t been impressed.
If you’re comparing an amp with hundreds to thousands of hours of use to something fresh off the floor, my guess is yes the speaker break-in is playing a considerable role :)
 
If you’re comparing an amp with hundreds to thousands of hours of use to something fresh off the floor, my guess is yes the speaker break-in is playing a considerable role :)
It's hard to tell how many hours are on an amp or speaker from looking at the amp or the player. It's not like they have an hour meter displayed on the front panel.
 
It's hard to tell how many hours are on an amp or speaker from looking at the amp or the player. It's not like they have an hour meter displayed on the front panel.
I bet if you ask the owner they can ballpark how many hours they’ve spent with their gear though.
 
Back
Top Bottom