Hi Stratman68,
Got to agree entirely with RevDrucifer, this is life changing stuff, especially in a small room. I spent about 3 years using a spare room similar size to yours with no acoustic treatment. The low frequency reverberation build up was a major limitation to listening pleasure, and made mixing anything with much low end impossible.
I was lucky enough to be able to have a home studio built this year, and the control room is a little bigger than your room (and my old one), but the acoustic treatment has worked out amazingly well. Mine is all done with rock-wool insulation of varying density, hidden by fabric wall coverings.
Bass traps in the corners made the biggest difference. They are pretty wide (maybe 18"), and filled with a high density - low density - high density sandwich of insulation in all 4 corners of the room over the full room height. Most of the rest of the treatment is just 4" thick low density insulation, covering most of the back wall, most of the front wall, and then at potential reflection points on the side walls. We played around a tiny bit with moving the insulation once I had playback gear in there. There's also a big slab of insulation in the ceiling directly above my listening position, mainly because I have relatively reflective laminate floor.
What really helped with the experimentation was making measurements, particularly of reverberation time against frequency. If you have even basic recording facilities in your PC, and preferably a responsive condenser mic, ideally a purpose made measurement mic, then Room EQ Wizard (REW) is amazingly useful:
https://www.roomeqwizard.com/
If you use this you can often identify inadequacies in build up of particular frequencies because of their long reverberation times. My baseline was the old spare room, because I knew it was pretty hopeless, and early measurements with REW and an old C1000s confirmed this beyond doubt. I'd strongly recommend making measurements without treatment at the listening position, and then moving treatment around to see what happens. The ideal is to get ever decreasing reverberation times as frequency goes up. If you want to know which frequencies you need to kill, the amroc calculator is very easy to use, and definitely picks the right frequencies for the few rooms that I have modelled, designed and measured.
https://amcoustics.com/tools/amroc
As to whether there is any point? Jeez, where do I start, it's just incredible. I started out using exactly the same gear (Scarlett 6i6 into Adam A5X), on the same stands as I had in the old room. The frequency and stereo separation is absolutely amazing. If I'm listening to albums I know well I can hear
really obviously the completely different feel of the tracks that were mastered in different suites, or recorded in different studios. I am finding subtleties in low and high end registers that I never even knew were there. I haven't really got started on recording much (see my other thread...
), but I don't care so much, because everything I listen to, and everything I play in there is like a new experience.
Could you achieve a similar epiphany with foam wedges and some panels? I reckon you will get much of the way there. Wedges in the vertical corners, back wall to start with, front wall as well if you can. Put them at speaker height if you can, so they are trapping the bass at its maximum intensity. Then for the flat panels, try to find the reflection points on the side walls where sound will arrive at your ears as first reflection. This way you should only hear what's coming out of the speakers once (initially at least, the reverberations never go away...) Importantly, make measurements of how the room and the sound system interact, using REW, as you make any changes. I tend to put the measurement mic right next to my right ear when checking the right channel, and vice versa for the left.
Pretty good description of placement in this article:
https://www.soundonsound.com/techniques/studio-sos-guide-monitoring-acoustic-treatment
Make sure you let us know how you get on. You might find you want to get some more panels and wedges.
My experience with the control room has been jaw-dropping. I haven't yet decided if the live room has worked out perfectly, which surprised me as it's the room I spent most time in detail designing the acoustics. Full band with acoustic drums was always going to be an issue in a relatively small space (14' x 19').
I thought the control room was too small to sound good, but I'm most likely going to get a sub speaker in there soon, which I had thought was going to be pointless given the potential difficulties of controlling bass reverberation. Turned out to be a bit easier than I had hoped.
Apologies for the long reply, first time I thought about rationalizing what I've been doing in my spare time for the last 14 months!
Liam