Just some thoughts related to this discussion:
1) I had the same JBL Control 10s monitors for decades, old school, used for several purposes over the years, were surprisingly good for home monitoring and recording when that came into my world. Anyway, when it was time to replace 8 years ago, I said to myself "this next set could be the set I use for another 2 decades, so let's aim for the best fit, and realize it's an investment that counts over the long haul.
2) Now that was a complicated way to say "it's ok to spend a little high of my immediate budget". The harder part, is more directly related to this discussion: what are the best monitors for....
3) For me, they have to sound great playing reference recordings. If my target is to create, record, and mix, I want to know that final product sounds great on my system. But they also need to be "pro" enough to handle guitar music with accuracy, clarity, and power. The entire system also has to have a methodical tuning path.
4) Now if recording mixing isn't your thing, and youre coming from an amp sounding setup, then I'm guessing thats possibly a different target. My brother is an exclusive amp player, and he asks me "when you are alone do you really crank it up?". Well my answer is no, I want it to sound great at monitor listening position and levels (and also headphones).
I know all that is obvious to all on this discussion, but sometimes it's worth mentioning, and helps you reign in what youre REALLY shooting for.
- Do you have amp friends that come over to jam with you?
- Do you need volume and presence to compete with amp players?
- How often do you listen to recordings of other music, and how much of an audiophile are you?
- Of course everyone talks about room treatment and layout, including sitting position etc.
For all of us, with our fractals, guitars, basses, keyboards, computers, softwares, musical ideas, volume knobs: the true challenge and goal is envisioning WHAT we want to achieve, and then craft the art of our talent, ears, and piles of tools to create.
Happy Sunday!