When I played in a band that had a more varied song selection I had around a half-dozen patches that I used depending on the song. Broadly speaking I had:
- SLO100 with clean, rhythm, lead (I spent most of my time here)
- Marshall with clean, rhythm, lead, whammy, and wah (you might be able to guess which band this was primarily for)
- Acoustic simulator with a pushed Tubescreamer lead tone via some kind of Fender
- Mesa Mark II dialied for stiffer, lower-gain 70s/80s studio session-type work
- Bandmaster with a bunch of random effects out front for indie/90s stuff
As I've grown wiser and lazier I've basically replaced all of this with a single "kitchen sink"-type patch and have learned to alter my playing to accommodate a lot of these tones. I live on a single preset with a single cabinet and only two (?!) amp channels:
- A medium-gain crunch tone with enough bass content and a dialed bright cap that has barely enough gain to do crunchy power chords that also dials back into an 8/10 clean. I use this for 75% of the evening and ride my guitar volume to get everything that I need. This is typically an SLO Crunch or some kind of 800.
- A high-gain tone that's a bit more sculpted (fewer mids, tighter, bass, and maybe a hair more Presence) that I use for leads and heavier (Nu Metal-adjacent) rhythms.
If I need something to be pushed or "tweed" sounding I roll back volume on my crunch tone and play towards the neck pickup with looser muting. If I need something to be tighter I palm mute farther away from the bridge or kick to the gainier channel. From here I build a dual-output signal path that has the amp and post FX going straight to Out2 and a Cab block with some gentle compression going to Out1. This way I can do both or one of a guitar cabinet or FRFR/FOH respectively.
For specific songs I'll pepper in a pitch block (anything Rage, "99 Quite Bitter Beings") or sundry other modulation ("Plush") effects but that's basically it. Unless there's a specific need for an effect based on our setlist I don't bother adding it to the preset... keeping it simple lets me focus on playing, singing, crowd interaction, etc. and I only really have one preset to tweak when things get updated.
Side note - I think a big part of the reason that some people are overwhelmed by modeling is because they feel obligated to use every single effect and Youtuber-introduced trick at their disposal instead of just building a rig analogously to how they would IRL. Ever since I've settled on the SLO being my One True Amp (influencers and forumites be damned about it "not being tight enough", "having congested low mids", etc) and having a single notional rig built around it I've spent a lot more time
actually making music and less time dicking around with the hundreds of amps available in the box. JMO, YMMV, etc.
As an aside I'm really hoping that
@FractalAudio eventually releases a pedal-sized amp modeler. At the very least I'll buy it so that I can keep it in my guitar case as a backup, but if I can figure out a small multi-FX like a Zoom Multistomp (or a VP1, hint hint ;-) to pair it with then I just might ditch my FM3+FC6 setup altogether and save myself from dragging an extra case to gigs and rehearsal.
Thanks for coming to my TED talk.