I have real PAF's, and the truth is they varied greatly over the years (I have had them since the early 70's), so saying one modern clone is realer than another is kind of impossible.
As long as the basic construction techniques and components are ballpark, at that point it's totally subjective, so just use the ones you like best for all the other variables that need to be taken into account like guitar construction, scale length, string type, bridge type, pick, playing style, player skill, music style and amp/cab choice, etc, etc, etc.