Amp or Axe-FX III?

[Domct203]

So, what’s your guess & why?

Both tracks are from a 15 year old Zoom 16 Track Digital Recorder, recorded in stereo with no post processing, Beat Buddy on the drums.

Same guitar and pickups on both tracks.

NOMAD Sunrise:


The Journey:

 

[Bertotti]

In all honesty I can’t really tell. I’m on my phone no ear buds or anything just made a guess. Might change my mind if I get to some really speakers but even then recorded unless I heard the pieces in the same room I wouldn’t be able to tell with certainty. On a phone with the phone speakers no way to be sure.