Ibanez vs Gibson Les Paul? Could've also been the title.
FEEDBACK!!
Well the graphics betray it even before listening: the second high gain one obviously has more compression just by looking. ^^ (Which could be misleading, though).
For the clip, your ultra patches seem to have less bass too, but I'm listening on gaming headphones so it might be overdone.
I promised in another thread I'd do this "mean little trick" so here's the same riff played with both Ultra and Axe-Fx II with Ultra tone matched to have the same response as the II. So the difference is all in the dynamics which in high gain will be very small. But go ahead and take a guess which is which: