I tried FOUR TIMES to get through The Astonishing. Totally lost on me. But whether or not I like the newer stuff, I still pull up the songs on Songstrerr to see what crazy thing JP is coming up with. TBH, I no longer hear anything like, Erotomania, for example, but there's still some good writing going on. I just think their well is drying up, and Portnoy's production & arranging was a huge part of how interesting the song ended up.
And they seem to really be laying into 7/8 time signatures lately as well. But I'm really glad they got a Grammy, even if it is a popularity contest at its core.
JP is such a chill guy, but I bet his heart was racing more than before they play their opening song at a show, right before they announced the winner. I'm glad he was there to receive it!