So, being a self-admitted "classic Van Halen" fan, I stopped really listening to their new music after OU812... Roth-era is Van Halen to me.
I liked those first couple Hagar-era albums (I was already a Hagar fan), but it wasn't "my" idea of what VH should be. I did own For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge and Balance but I'm not sure I could name a tune from either album.
When Sammy was booted, I really was fed up with the VH brothers's behavior (much like what happened with my opinion of Gene Simmons and Paul Stanley from KISS). I'd had enough and stopped supporting them...
So I never heard a single track from Van Halen III until today. I listened to several... There wasn't anything "bad" about them IMO but still not the VH that I want to listen to.
I was also a fan of Gary Cherone being an early fan of Extreme (who I originally thought might be the second coming of VH).
Listening to VH III or struck me that Cherone has a lot in common with Hagar.
Anyway, quite a long windup to my point:
I think Eddie had some very different and cool tones going on this album! There's a certain "girth" to some of the chord work that I don't recall from other albums.
Back when it came out, I would probably have liked this music if I'd never have heard classic VH or if it was done under a different name...
Anyway, just some thoughts. I'm sure some will disagree
I think you're missing out. To me, the Hagar and Cherone records had the best of what Eddie's playing was to become. The instrumentals "Balutchetherium" from
Balance, "Respect the Wind" from the
Twister soundtrack, and "Catherine" from that porn flick was all of his soul and fire dumped into his fingers. I still love those tracks. I love all of Ed's instrumentals, primarily because they were unfettered by having to serve the lyric - intro, verse, chorus, verse, chorus, bridge, solo, chorus x 2, outro. He was able to just unleash whatever was on his mind.
Dave held him back and getting back together was for you older-timey fans, the first-gen who's world was shaken to its very core by "Eruption", or so it would seem by what everyone else who was around at that time has always said. I really think Eddie was out of fight by about 2010 and just wanted to seal in the legacy before time ran out, which is why Dave was back in the band and ADKOT was made, along with recording at least one album with Wolf, which always to me appeared to be a primary underlying motivation.
5150 came out when I was in 6th grade and it roped me in, so I've been a Hagar-era kid. The earlier stuff from the first Dave years that I liked were the least popular, non-single VH songs, i.e. the one
not traditionally in heavy rotation on classic rock radio stations, like "And the Cradle Will Rock..."and "Hot for Teacher". Gimme "Secrets", "Drop Dead Legs", and "Little Guitars". 1984 was 3rd/4th grade for me and I knew about VH from MTV and the "Jump" and "Panama" videos but the rest of the stuff wasn't really in the water yet, so to speak. What hit my ear holes was highly dependent on what mom wanted to listen to when she was keeping house, so it was a lot (and I mean a lot) of Stevie Nicks and Fleetwood Mac.
A Different Kind of Truth was, to me, a regression. It was also,
in my opinion, boring to listen to. It came out eight years ago and I listened to it maybe twice in total. From a guitar standpoint the riffs were just kinda there, the solos were pedestrian and basically it was just a platform for Dave's endless bullshit. There, I said it. Instead of pushing forward, the whole album was a treadmill of throwaway stuff.
I'm just throwing thoughts over the fence, too. I don't live or die by them. I'm just writing for the sake of writing.