I’d love to see a steel cage match with 4 desks and mics, a debate between all the modeler CEOs on which product is the best and why
Fractal
L6
HR
QC
Only one leaves alive.
View attachment 89013Latest measurements.
Purple is Axe-Fx III. Blue is a new thing.
Aliasing is especially poor in the high frequencies. Usually the aliasing spectrum is sort of flat (like the Axe-Fx). With this product the aliasing increases with frequency which is odd.
Model used was JCM800. All controls at noon except Presence at zero. Gain was matched.
You're not understanding what the graphs mean. Anything other than the input signal and its harmonics is "noise". In this case aliasing noise.Healthy boost around 100hz, steady rise from 1khz. Reminds me of a PEQ simulation of speaker impedance curve.
Are you sure this behavior isn't intended?
That will prove nothing. This is a test of aliasing performance. The cab block is not even used in these tests.Take a Capture of the model in the AXE and compare those. Then Tone Match the model in the QC and compare those.
That will prove nothing. This is a test of aliasing performance. The cab block is not even used in these tests.
Aliasing is a purely digital artifact. A real amp in the analog domain has no aliasing.So you are proving that Neural needs to work on the aliasing of their models. What does the graph of a real amp look like?
Aliasing is a purely digital artifact. A real amp in the analog domain has no aliasing.
I haven't named a particular manufacturer or product.So you are proving that Neural needs to work on the aliasing of their models. What does the graph of a real amp look like?
I was thinking we'd peel Fractal off the top of the list, and toss a $10 bill and a knife in the middle of the remaining three and see what happens.I’d love to see a steel cage match with 4 desks and mics, a debate between all the modeler CEOs on which product is the best and why
Fractal
L6
HR
QC
Only one leaves alive.
Treat them like children. Give the bigger ones large sticks and the little ones sharp objects so they have a fighting chance.I was thinking we'd peel Fractal off the top of the list, and toss a $10 bill and a knife in the middle of the remaining three and see what happens.
The Boss IR-200 will not be available until January 2022. I guess it is a more expensive product that was presented with a quite aggressive marketing campaignI bet this is the Boss IR-200
Since you don't know what the product is, how can you claim to be comparing it?Are those results supposed to be remarkably bad for the ‘new thing’ compared to Fractal? As in audible in normal use to a large degree?
If so why don’t I hear it since I’m literally AB comparing them daily through the same FRFR and also same tube power amp and guitar cab?
is it possible this is only so disparate with the 800 model? Or is it going to be the same with all models?
Is it the same using captures?