Don't get me wrong openmind, it was a great, great guitar. I was playing through a fender amp of some description in a shop and it sounded fantastic, as good as anything else I tried. I think I had just built the thing up in my head and expected some kind of mystic voodoo in the neck. It was an Antique Custom I tried. I actually set out to buy the thing, and drove quite a way to get there. But I didn't feel that magic, I'm sure you know the feeling I'm talking about. Some guitars you pick up and feel like you never want to stop playing.
Like you said, it's a very personal thing in the end. Tbh I kind of regret posting the original comment, it sounds like a challenge to Suhr owners which it certainly is not. I guess I was just saying I didn't connect with the one I tried.
