An underrated guitar solo would be one that flies under the radar of most guitar players. Pagey's solo on Stairway to Heaven or Claptons on Crossroads could not be underrated. Or it could be a solo from a well known guitarist in a well known band on a well known CD, yet no one has mentioned this small, short solo. Or a not often heard, specialty genre, some bluegrass picker unknown out of Nashville, or some brilliant jazz guitarist like Ben Monder or Adam Rogers. He maybe well known in his small circle but the general guitar playing public is unaware.
So basically a solo that is not from a popular song that sounds good and has a good musical structure and inspires you in some sort of way.
Hmmm... being more of an rhythm guitarist (coloring chords/arrangements and stuff myself) I´m not that much into solo in the first place.
Although not under-rated but I am a bit surprised that 10 pages on in this thread and still no mention of Mike McCready (Pearl Jam).
I´m not so fancy of his (or anyones) shredding, but when it sounds like he´s fighting some inner demons and the way he´s working his wah-wah in some of his solos is pure magnificient IMHO... kinda rips up and torching skies with it (Go from album VS are my favourite in that manner).
IF we would have talked about under-rated rhythm guitarist, I would say Thom Yorke (yes, the singer). He´s got some really amazing grooves (i e Bodysnatchers and he´s singing at the same time) and adds great textures sometimes...
Oh, and I love Josh Hommes anti-(guitar)hero attitude!
To me it sounds so simplistic that it has a childish or I'm new to the guitar quality to it
No, that actually not quite what I saud, or not what I meant to say. I said it could have been from a well known guitarist, well known band, well known song yet the solo was seldom remarked upon.
Della Brown; Queensryche. Chris Degarmo - solo 1 and 2, Michael Wilton - outro solo. A great study in "metal guitarists" taking their time with lead parts and paying attention to phrasing.
Yeah, of course. How can you quantify it? It's all subjective. And who knows. I might discover someone who is new to me and I think he's under appreciated yet well known. I used to like Dave Masons solo on Look at You, Look at Me. Who is to say whether it's underrated? I've never heard anyone talk about it. And it's not an earth shattering solo, but I always liked it. Who's to say? We are. That's all.Ok, so then it basically boils down to what an individual likes that no one else has noticed in guitar playing? seems pretty broad. IDK maybe I'm just having a hard time with this topic.
Every solo ever performed by Martin Barre