...rack our brains, changing IR's and 700 different potential settings to get our "sound" back. Even starting from scratch I likely wouldnt have gone straight to presence. any other tips out there?
You wouldn't have gone to treble and presence after losing the high end (muffled blanket)? I don't get that.
This is how I do it:
1 - figure out what changed: gain, master, lows, mids, highs
2 - go to the knob/knobs associated with the change
3 - if that doesn't recapture it, then I change the cabinet & revisit 1&2
If it's a texture, dynamics, response or frequency specific mojo, the basics will still get me at least 80% there. Then it's off to the eq, compression, damp, dynamic, definition.
If that doesn't get me to 90%, I go to input trim, transformer match and transformer drive.
With the Lemur axe-fx editor I can do the entire process in under 15 minutes. Usually in 5-10, even with a tricky re-dial.
That means I've hit the treble or presence in seconds and everything else in a few minutes. Then I navigate very quickly between it all to get the tone where I want. This is possible with the Lemur axe-fx editor (see my sig). It makes short work of redialing after big firmware updates. Touchscreen is the way to go. I'm not affiliated with Scrutinizer, I just enjoy working with his editing template.