I can say that I have not tried any pedals of late. I am at the point where I want portability, ease of set up and simplicity. Personally, all fo my performances are through FOH. I really doubt that the vast majority of my audiences are tone connoisseurs. I am NOT saying pearls before swine, but I am saying that the FAS sounds are very compelling and inspiring for me as a player. At the business end of the speakers, I really doubt that the average listener is so discriminating. I think for most of the audiences I play for the listening experience boils down to, "I like it or I don't like it". That judgement is based on the overall sound of the music, not the tone of the guitar player.
I don’t think audiences care for nuance, but there certainly plenty of songs with a pretty unique tone. You could certainly play a song like “spirit in the sky” through a cranked Marshall and it would sound “fine”, but if you play it with a Jordan BossTone, and your teles tone pot rolled al the way off, it does have a certain something extra, capturing that true 60’s raw fuzz tone.
this one seems to sound great on youtube.
The Fulltone Soulbender is a nice fuzz tone with a telecaster.
Dweezil Zappa uses a lot of different fuzz tones. He has found a lot of good ones. You can hear him demo them in these videos.
I daresay the average listener pays 10x more attention to your singer then to your tone.
Maybe to you, but again, the average listener is paying 10x more attention to your singer then to you. As long you're playing what the listener expects to hear tone will not matter one bit, except the tone connaisseur. A.K.A. the guitar player in the audience. But you're never going to please him anyway, as the only thing that will satisfy him is taking your place.
By that logic we probably need not show up with a $2500 Axe III, any old modeler would suffice fine. Or heck, we could actually just stay home and let a singer do their thing to a backing track lol.
In all serious, I think it depends on the type of music your playing, if vocals are even a big part of your act etc. I played more jam band type stuff where we didn’t really have much in the way of vocals (nor much of an audience lol) but I do think the overall guitar tones, effects et al, where a big part of the sound, and a part that the audience we had was into. Essentially we made crazy noisy for other dudes who would stand around and appreciate us making crazy noises lol.
Fun times, but certainly a world apart from playing brown eyed girl at a wedding reception type of audience
If you want that Octave Fuzz sound the only thing that comes close is the Roger Mayer
I'm a huge fan of the Slash Octave Fuzz- it's like Prince in a box
My favorite pedal- not a traditional fuzz- but is all over the place in terms of what it can do- Zvex Fuzz Factory
BUT you can start cheap with a dunlop or big muff- I hate fuzz so you might start with that before diving into something better