RevDrucifer
Fractal Fanatic
Did Metallica release all those notes? I did see a YouTube video of someone discussing those a while back. Seemed like acquiring all the gear today would be quite a task.
I'm with you on the secrecy thing. I've been chasing Devs tone for a while now, while the preset they released is very cool it does seem like a very ballpark version of his sound. The GP sound isn't there, which is the main "Dev" thing. He's said multiple times it would get released and it never has. Latest is it will get released with a Neural DSP plugin. Not holding my breath!
I thought the notes were released in a box set or special release they did. Lemme do some diggin'-
Seems it was Flemming Rasmussen who posted them on his website- http://www.fwrproduction.com/FWR_Produktion/Notes_1.html
In this case, I'm not sure if Flemming asked the band if it was ok, or didn't bother being that they were his notes. While I don't know the relationship between the band and Flemming, my knee jerk reaction is to say if the band asked him, he would have taken them down.
I think the reason why I don't believe they're all that secretive is because I've never heard James or Kirk say as much. I've been a pretty avid fan for quite some time, read every interview I've ever come across, especially if it was a Hetfield interview, and don't recall ever seeing them say "We don't want you to know that.". I think it's more of a situation that the guys have always relied on producers/engineers to get the sounds on the albums. I'd be quite surprised if they even actually knew exactly what ended up on the records and exactly how everything was dialed in.
Take for instance, Bob Rock on the Year And A Half doc, when Kirk is tracking the solo for "The Unforgiven"-
When Kirk asks if he can use a thicker sound, Bob's reply is to go back to his regular sound and he'll put it through an amp later because he doesn't want to fuck around with sounds. While I'm sure the guys always had plenty of input, at the end of the day, it was the producers/engineers pushing the knobs and especially in the case of Rock, they hired him specifically to get the sound he was known for. He had them trying all kinds of stuff and I'd be willing to bet James and Kirk were sitting in the control room while someone else was out turning knobs on amps, waiting for them to say "Yeah, I dig that.".
Tl;dr- I'm sure James and Kirk can tell you their ballpark settings, but I highly doubt they can go into great detail due to being more focused on the final product and not so much being tone nuts. They've always been open about what they use as far as guitars, amps and effects and even describing the tones they dig, but I'm not so sure they're that involved in the engineering/mixing process to give anymore information than that.