Out 1 Main should NOT be set to maximum in all situations.I’ve read that Out 1 (Main) should be set to maximum for unity gain. I set all my presets to about half volume on Out 1 before I learnt of this. Does the position affect tone or anything other than volume?
This topic has many threads
In my experience, you can run the Out 1 Level knob really anywhere without any added noise or issue. I usually recommend starting at 9 o clock and going up to 3 o clock if needed, especially if you are not control of the mixer or next device at a gig.
Some recommend turning all the way up for best signal to noise ratio, but I’ve honestly never heard any “noise” from keeping it lower. I’d love to hear some if anyone has experienced this. Whenever someone mentions noise or is afraid of noise, I imagine they hear a static sound that’s 10x louder than their guitar playing haha. I’ve never experienced an issue like this ever in audio when it comes to XLR vs 1/4”, low vs high output knob, etc.
Some also recommend turning all the way up and then keeping your mixer or interface preamp gain turned all the way down to prevent coloration from the preamps. Again, I personally have not had any issue with this. But maybe something to keep in mind. Some say they hear the difference, but try it for yourself and see if it’s an actual issue.
However, at most live performances where you don’t control the mixer, the sound engineer will not run his channels with the gain all the way down. They are just not used to this and for some reason most think they HAVE to have some gain on the channel or “it won’t sound good” or even “doesn’t work.” This is not true at all, but I’m there to play music, not convince a sound guy how to do his job or teach how gear works. Because of this you rarely will be able to turn your AX8 all the way up at a gig (and you don’t need to anyway). They will immediately tell you to turn down because you’re sending too much signal, all while their channel gain is set to 12 o clock - the best and required setting for mixers!!! (That is a joke.)
So that’s why I recommend the range of 9 o clock to 3 o clock, working with the sound guy to get what he wants from your gear. Again, in 10 years of using the Axe gear, I’ve never ever had issue with running less than full volume - it’s a volume knob, it’s there to be turned down and the range used. If it was meant to turn all the way up, there wouldn’t be a knob (like how the FX8 is designed).
Unity Gain means what goes in comes out. Unity gain is initially measured with SHUNTS only. Once you add an Amp block or other level changing block, you aren’t at unity gain and usually much louder. So blindly turning all the way up to “be at unity gain” is usually not accurate and louder, not at unity gain. You can be at unity gain with a full preset, you just have to set the level that way specifically.
Because you’re in a recording environment, you can use techniques like the ones shown in this thread and other similar techniques where you use a DAW to help you level your presets to achieve true Unity Gain for a particular consistent level, thus with your AX8 turned up all the way both for consistency (hard stop on the knob) and best signal to noise ratio.
But what you’re doing is probably working just as well without added noise or issue at all.
On a forum and the internet in general, there will be a range of acceptable practices and techniques when it comes to gear. Because of this range, there will always be people who suggest the absolute most ideal way of doing whatever is in question. Nothing wrong with this at all if the information is factual and correct, which many times it is. But this “most ideal” answer usually doesn’t work in multiple situations and also might require additional gear or knowledge or processes which make a simple task seem very daunting.
That’s why it’s good to have multiple views and answers that fit different situations, and hopefully the person asking can compare and use what works best for them.
Think of threads like “best monitor” or “best cables” or best anything really. You have some people suggesting $10,000 speakers or $300 cables and it can make people think using the Fractal gear is way too hard or expensive. Well... the question did ask for the “best” and to some people the most expensive is the best. But usually people mean “best for my situation.” So maybe a $200 speaker is what is needed.
A bit of a tangent, but this topic comes up almost weekly and I just want to provide some perspective for new users who may see the first response of “you must use a $10,000 speaker”, and then freak out because someone on the internet said so.
Thank you, that’s very helpful.Out 1 Main should NOT be set to maximum in all situations.
Unity gain is measured with Shunts only. Once you add other blocks, you are probably louder than Unity Gain.
Use the volume knob as a volume knob. It will not change anything other than volume/level coming out of the AX8. Here are more of my thoughts on this:
https://forum.fractalaudio.com/threads/a-few-questions-about-foh.142368/#post-1689559
Worth noting that this topic comes up all the time and what Chris says here is his opinion that some of us disagree with.Out 1 Main should NOT be set to maximum in all situations.
Unity gain is measured with Shunts only. Once you add other blocks, you are probably louder than Unity Gain.
Use the volume knob as a volume knob. It will not change anything other than volume/level coming out of the AX8. Here are more of my thoughts on this:
https://forum.fractalaudio.com/threads/a-few-questions-about-foh.142368/#post-1689559
The definition of Unity Gain:The knob set to max is "unity gain" by what anyone reasonably means by "unity gain" when they ask about this i.e. if you imagine rewiring the AX8 to get rid of that knob, the max level is the setting that will be the equivalent to that.
Do you have tremolo springs on the guitar? Stuff a napkin in there and they’ll stop ringing.Thanks, that’s interesting. I don’t have a noise problem with one exception - I get what I call ‘ring out’ when damping a heavily distorted sound off with the heel of my hand - no reverb added but it rings out like it has. I can completely eliminate this through judicious use of a gate.
Back to the original question: do you actually want Unity Gain?I’ve read that Out 1 (Main) should be set to maximum for unity gain. I set all my presets to about half volume on Out 1 before I learnt of this. Does the position affect tone or anything other than volume?
Some have experimented and they say that Unity Gain is achieved when the preset is leveled at the mid-line on the VU meter and the Out 1 knob is all the way up.As far as I understand it unlike the Axe-Fx and FX8, the AX8 is not designed for unity gain at all. If you want unity gain, you'd need to do some experiments.
Do you have tremolo springs on the guitar? Stuff a napkin in there and they’ll stop ringing.
If not, rarely the strings above the nut will ring out.
As far as I know, what you are referring to is true when referring to gain from the input of the piece of Fractal gear to the output but unity gain is measurable across different points in a signal chain.As far as I understand it unlike the Axe-Fx and FX8, the AX8 is not designed for unity gain at all. If you want unity gain, you'd need to do some experiments.
just to clarify, it seems you are defining "Unity Gain" as 2 different things, yes? one meaning "what goes in comes out" - which is the typical definition. another meaning "turning the Out 1 knob all the way up."The goal here is to maintain instrumental level. I don't have any experience with the FX8 but I'd have to think that this is the same as the AX8 where it is only valid to claim "unity gain" across input to output when using all shunts as it is common to use overdrives, boosters, etc. to intentionally introduce gain.
...
When someone asks about "unity gain" with regard to the AX8's OUT1, it is typically pretty clear from the context what they mean i.e. they are asking about optimal gain staging. In the context of a mixer, optimal gain staging with the AX8 is typically going to be with the OUT1 at max (i.e. unity gain for the OUT1 knob not the AX8 itself) and the input gain on the mixer set at 0 (i.e. unity gain for the mixer channel preamp).
and i have to comment directly on this statement - i disagree that it's "pretty clear" they mean optimal gain staging. yes, ultimately they want optimal gain staging, but the tutorial videos specifically use the term "Unity Gain" to mean what goes in comes out - the traditional (only) definition of "Unity Gain."When someone asks about "unity gain" with regard to the AX8's OUT1, it is typically pretty clear from the context what they mean i.e. they are asking about optimal gain staging.
i completely agree with this. generally you want the most Source level before clipping the next device in the chain. the main problem with the "Out knob all the way up" approach though is venues and sound engineers have channels pre-set usually with the Mixer Channel trim/gain set to "12:00" roughly. there is some common "rule" in many sound guy's minds that you shouldn't run the mixer with the channel trim less than 12:00.If you knock the signal on the AX8 down by 10dB with OUT1, you would need to turn up the mixer input gain accordingly to compensate. That sort of thing tends to be frowned upon because, for one thing, you are amplifying noise (whether you personally can hear it or care about it or not).
to my understanding, this is actually what those "unity gain" tutorials are trying to accomplish. i don't think they ever specifically say they want an instrument level coming out. but they typically have a specific goal for the output hitting their DAW - is it -12dB if i remember correctly?For the AX8, where in typical operation it takes an instrument level input and produces a line level output emulating a full signal chain from pedalboard to mic preamp, the concept of unity gain from input to output doesn't really make much sense to talk about. The device, by design, adds gain and you aren't typically trying to produce a guitar level output from it.
the middle line on the VU meter is just a reference, true. but it is a good reference because it provides ample headroom for boosts in the future.you can still have 0 gain at the mixer by increasing Level in the preset to achieve channel unity at the mixer, which, if I understand correctly, should not add any noise or color the tone. Naturally, the preset will likely then be above the "unity" line on the VU meter, but as long as the signal is not clipping, does it make a difference?
Yes- Output1 on the Ax8 also controls the S/PDIF digital out signal. This is not the case on the Axe-Fx. If you want a Factory preset to come in at around - 12db using the S/PDIF into a DAW without adding any gain at the DAW end, you need to turn the Output1 to the max.@Dave76, @chris and @austinbuddy - I guess the question I have, and maybe many others is simply - Does it matter? The reason i ask is because I'm under the impression that if you run Output 1 at 50%, you can still have 0 gain at the mixer by increasing Level in the preset to achieve channel unity at the mixer, which, if I understand correctly, should not add any noise or color the tone. Naturally, the preset will likely then be above the "unity" line on the VU meter, but as long as the signal is not clipping, does it make a difference? (this question is really only as to sound quality, I understand the "ease of use" benefit of trying to hit the VU meter unity for all my patches)
I am not defining unity gain as two different things. The term "gain" and "unity gain" have very precise technical definitions in the field of electronics. "Gain" is quite simply the ratio of output level to input. "Unity" quite simply means a ratio of 1:1 i.e. the output level is identical to the input level. "Unity" without a further qualification such as "unity gain" has no more meaning than if you walked up to the counter in a deli and declared "I will have one!" (though I wouldn't be surprised if some audio equipment manufacturers have abused the term).just to clarify, it seems you are defining "Unity Gain" as 2 different things, yes? one meaning "what goes in comes out" - which is the typical definition. another meaning "turning the Out 1 knob all the way up."
"Unity Gain" specifically means what goes in comes out.
describing a knob all the way up, a mixer trim/gain set at 0, or a mixer fader set at the -0- line is called "Unity." not "Unity Gain."
Totally agreed on this! That's why I said "If you are in a situation with confused and stubborn sound man, you gotta do what you gotta do..." in my first reply to this post. I always try to point this out when I try to explain the function of the OUT1 knob. I'm simply advocating that in an ideal world, you should have no issues with the OUT1 knob set to max and that this will give you maximum signal-to-noise in the downstream signal chain. If you have to turn it down, go for it.i completely agree with this. generally you want the most Source level before clipping the next device in the chain. the main problem with the "Out knob all the way up" approach though is venues and sound engineers have channels pre-set usually with the Mixer Channel trim/gain set to "12:00" roughly. there is some common "rule" in many sound guy's minds that you shouldn't run the mixer with the channel trim less than 12:00.
so we have one guy saying "i'm not allowed to turn below 12:00 trim on my mixer" vs another guy saying "i'm not allowed to turn Out 1 knob down from 100%." who wins? this happens time and time again. i get PMs all the time about this, and we have threads about this constantly.
i see.I am not defining unity gain as two different things. The term "gain" and "unity gain" have very precise technical definitions in the field of electronics. "Gain" is quite simply the ratio of output level to input. "Unity" quite simply means a ratio of 1:1 i.e. the output level is identical to the input level. "Unity" without a further qualification such as "unity gain" has no more meaning than if you walked up to the counter in a deli and declared "I will have one!" (though I wouldn't be surprised if some audio equipment manufacturers have abused the term).
You can measure gain across a multitude of different circuit elements along the signal path. As such, it is important to either clarify or determine from context exactly what part of the signal path someone is referring to when they are discussing unity gain. When someone asks about the OUT1 knob, I assume they probably mean the OUT1 knob, in which case unity gain as measured across that knob is when the knob is set at max i.e. the equivalent of replacing with a wire. I'm honestly not even sure it typically makes sense to discuss "unity gain" across the input to output of the AX8 given how much signal processing is typically used (i.e. the output signal differs by much more than a simple multiplication of the input by a gain factor).
Contrast this with the input gain knob on a mixer channel. Unity gain across the head amp in that case is when the gain is set to 0 i.e. the equivalent of replacing with a wire. Take a look at the back of a lot of powered monitors and unity gain is often with the knob in the halfway position. This is vital to understand to get the optimal performance out of the equipment.
Totally agreed on this! That's why I said "If you are in a situation with confused and stubborn sound man, you gotta do what you gotta do..." in my first reply to this post. I always try to point this out when I try to explain the function of the OUT1 knob. I'm simply advocating that in an ideal world, you should have no issues with the OUT1 knob set to max and that this will give you maximum signal-to-noise in the downstream signal chain. If you have to turn it down, go for it.