It sounds like hyperbole, especially when it is the same people claiming the same thing with every single update.
Not sure how long you have been on the forum but I think most of us that have been on here for several years use the phrase "more real" because we have seen the transition from when it didn't sound as "real". I've probably had my Axe-FX-II for three years or so and you would be amazed what has changed over time.
The main core tone coming from the amp emulations has not changed tremendously. It has been the "feel" that Cliff and Co. have been able to capture. Years ago, there were no tube choices, cathode options, IR capture, Tone Match, Pick Attack, Variac, etc., etc. I could go on and on. The point is that all of those things have made this unit, which is essentially a computer, become more "real".
But "more" means exactly that. Each update can truly be "more" without exaggerating.
Truth is truth , why boycott it? Really?
Yes, I get you. Thing is Chris, a lot of those same people jump all over anyone who dare question how good a certain model sounds. When that is the case, they then say it's exactly the same etc.
Anyway, going to watch the beta thread for a day or so more and if nothing major bug wise pops up, I might give it a go. Certainly interested to try it.
Good to see Fractal still chipping away at the unit to make it better.
Does it really matter if it is more or less "real"?
"What is real? How do you define 'real'? If you're talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then 'real' is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brain."
Stop making it harder than it needs to be. Find a setup you like and just play for a change..
There are always extremes on both ends of the scale. While I don't often agree with many of the posts admonishing critical comments I can somewhat understand that its the persons enthusiasm and zealousness with their gear. What I find puzzling though are the guys that purposely come here and/or to other gear forums with the sole intent of trolling. How shallow does your life have to be the have agendas like that? Yikes!
It would be nice if this forum could go back to the days where the vast majority of the posts were made along the lines of how can we make this community better, help FAS expand the capabilities of the Axe, and come up with creative ideas on usage as opposed to the ever more prevalent arguments on naming conventions, marketing, and business models.