Yes! It's totally false. As a matter of fact modes are so ridiculously easy, that guitar players often think it CAN'T be that easy, so they try and add layers of complexity to it to try and make it deep and then they get into serious deep water.I totally agree with you henry that lots of teachers and students over-complicate the fretboard. Myself included, really. I sometimes have to stop myself and tell myself not to over-think things.
Vinnie Moore has a great lesson on modes. Vinnie Moore(Great lesson on Modes)-part 1/3 - YouTube
I think the problem with modes is that they're often not explained very well, leading to confusion on the student's part. The student walks away thinking that the concept is hard and/or they're not good enough to do it. Totally false IMHO!!!
Slonimsky's book is WAY overkill. Decent foundation! OMG. That's very advanced stuff there. And they're not scales per se. They're treatments and interpolations and permutations. Not necessarily a lot of useful and applicable stuff. The guy wants a book of scales in TAB. LOL. IMHO of course!
Pretty much what I said earlier. Start with the 3 notes per string major scale. Make sure you take notice where the ROOT of the scale is. There will be 7 scale patterns each start on one of the 7 degrees of the scale. If you think of these degrees or steps as that rather than MODES you'll be better prepared.well Henry (ps I keep thinking your name says Bobbet, arrrrrrg that hurts)---you seem to "know" your stuff, care to share, or point us in the RIGHT direction? I would love to learn a bit more, but everytime I hit the scale books, I play the notes then my brain turns off. I just cant translate scales to music after playing by ear for 25 years.
About five minutes or so after I posted, I realized I did not preface what I wrote with: "Also.." or "In addition to.." I was lucky(?) to have a father who is a Jazz musician, a school friend guitarist whose Dad was an active professional guitarist, etc., so when I would read anything, I had people to turn to for some "practical application and translation." Not to mention having people to jam with every day after school, plus getting to hit clubs to jam. Having someone to interpret and such is vital, as has been suggested.Slonimsky's book is WAY overkill. Decent foundation! OMG. That's very advanced stuff there. And they're not scales per se. They're treatments and interpolations and permutations. Not necessarily a lot of useful and applicable stuff. The guy wants a book of scales in TAB. LOL. IMHO of course!