don_joe
Experienced
Hello good people!
I have an urge to replace my bridge pickup in my Carvin DC727 (maple neck/alder body, C26 bridge pickup with coil splitter). A week ago, I've played for a change my old Gibson SG for the first time with my AXE and I suddenly realised that I like the Alnico pickup sound better than this ceramic one from my DC727. That was the missing ingredient in the tone I was looking for. I would like to still play my 7-string guitar but with a warmer sound with more versatility. I believe it all comes to the pickup and I have only the bridge one in mind to be replaced. I'm not necessary looking for Alnico, I only like their tone quality. However, I just need something new to try out.
This is where I ask you for help, since I haven't been experimenting much and have not owned many guitars in my 30 years "career". Many of you know much better, so I was hoping to hear a few suggestions. I play a lot of high gain metal and when I play chugs palm muted, I like when the sound is tight and punchy but warm, without mud. On the other hand I like a good note separation when playing high gain chords, singing tones when playing solo and a tone that is suitable also for blues/rock/hard rock, kind of vintage. I don't play prog/djent but would like to be able to play it too with this same pup. It's hard to describe but it should be warm and at the same time not muddy in the bass (B-string should sound clear enough). It should roar without losing definition and warmth. I hope you get it...
The pickups that I found googling and could maybe be candidates as replacement are (all 7-string) Seymour Duncan JB SH-4 or maybe Bare Knuckle Nailbomb. There aren't that many useful videos on Youtube and it's hard for me to make a judgment, because many of those guys play heavily detuned or the sound is just too processed.
What is your experience and your recommendations? Which (passive) pickup is the best compromise between vintage and a high gain beast?
Thank you for your time and suggestions.
I have an urge to replace my bridge pickup in my Carvin DC727 (maple neck/alder body, C26 bridge pickup with coil splitter). A week ago, I've played for a change my old Gibson SG for the first time with my AXE and I suddenly realised that I like the Alnico pickup sound better than this ceramic one from my DC727. That was the missing ingredient in the tone I was looking for. I would like to still play my 7-string guitar but with a warmer sound with more versatility. I believe it all comes to the pickup and I have only the bridge one in mind to be replaced. I'm not necessary looking for Alnico, I only like their tone quality. However, I just need something new to try out.
This is where I ask you for help, since I haven't been experimenting much and have not owned many guitars in my 30 years "career". Many of you know much better, so I was hoping to hear a few suggestions. I play a lot of high gain metal and when I play chugs palm muted, I like when the sound is tight and punchy but warm, without mud. On the other hand I like a good note separation when playing high gain chords, singing tones when playing solo and a tone that is suitable also for blues/rock/hard rock, kind of vintage. I don't play prog/djent but would like to be able to play it too with this same pup. It's hard to describe but it should be warm and at the same time not muddy in the bass (B-string should sound clear enough). It should roar without losing definition and warmth. I hope you get it...
The pickups that I found googling and could maybe be candidates as replacement are (all 7-string) Seymour Duncan JB SH-4 or maybe Bare Knuckle Nailbomb. There aren't that many useful videos on Youtube and it's hard for me to make a judgment, because many of those guys play heavily detuned or the sound is just too processed.
What is your experience and your recommendations? Which (passive) pickup is the best compromise between vintage and a high gain beast?
Thank you for your time and suggestions.
Last edited:
No muddy bass frequencies when playing palm muting?