unFILTERed
Power User
That just means you have boomy setup
That just means any setup booms for me with those presets. And that just means Scott luvs the low end more than i do
That just means you have boomy setup
That just means any setup booms for me with those presets. And that just means Scott luvs the low end more than i do
this is exactly what I'm going to do when I get my CLR but against my RCF NX 12 (and hopefully a Xitone cab if Jay still has his when I get my CLR)
I'm hoping it wows me and I end up keeping it so I can run one out left and one out right.
Should be that cats meow
I'm not debating his opinion or preference. I am disagreeing with him on an objective and easily measurable point. His characterization does bear serious scrutiny given the manner it was presented.
You look at the following graphs and explain where the 'boomy' character exhibits itself. Laz is directly asserting the speaker cab itself is boomy. I disagree with him. Nothing more, nothing less. These charts are from Atomic.
... Scott has a wedge and Laz has a cab right? I know Jay says they sound the same.. but is it possible the cab is boomier?
No comment on this? If it was true, it would make Scott and LVC BOTH right, and only Jay would be wrong. Wouldn't that be fun?
So far I think only one other person said they have both but just got the CLR and have not gigged it yet. I have always wanted to hear more head to head to head reviews with the matrix, CLR and RCFAll this "boom" talk reminds me of a song> Cars (cabs) that go boom.... Cars That Go Boom - YouTube
"We like the cars the cars that go "BOOM>" We're tigre and bunny and we like the "boom." remember that tune..As bad as it was.......lol
Just agree to disagree an move on.............
Side note...Has anyone used the same preset and output L > to CLR and Output R> to Q12A and Visa Versa ? One on each side of you and turning each ear Visa Versa? That would probably end the discussion on "Boominess" lol
People saying that your personal opinon is wrong. That is one of the few things that p........... me off.
It´s like saying that someones guitarsound is "wrong"..... It´s not wrong. It´s personal.
Neutral observation:
If some people here don´t "like" each other: Please do PM each other. Nothing personal, but i think it´s best that those thing are settled offline, or at least off public forum. This may be the way things are on forums. And that may be the reason i don´t participate on other forums than this. It´s to many preachers. Lot of people who want to tell me how i feel. Don´t do that. Please.
Not to many here. I like this forum.
So.. What about this gear??
I´m sure both sound great. CLR´s are flat, no argument. But why does flat has to be the best for everyone??
People saying that your personal opinon is wrong. That is one of the few things that p........... me off.
It´s like saying that someones guitarsound is "wrong"..... It´s not wrong. It´s personal.
As i read it:
LVC never stated that what he said was facts. It was a reveiw. Opinion. Different from others. Maybe different from mine too. But that´s not relevant at all. It´s not me that writing the reveiw. If he think that the CLR is boomy. It is to him. Got nothing to do with how good or flat they are. He did not like them, and said why. If he just said: "i don´t like them", everyone would ask why. Personal opinion.
He got the Axe to work for him. With minimal effort. That is what every soul that gets any gear want. I like to tweak. But i want it to sound good without 100 hour pr preset. Some people won´t get it to work for them. Respect that. Try to help, but respect.
If i love something and others don´t like it, i may be surprised, but won´t tell them that they are wrong.
Hmmmm.. Unless i´m drunk... I could discuss forever when i´m drunk
Anyway
Modelers and amplifying are kind of complicated. You must find a modeler, then the the right amp, ir, effects, THEN the amplifying system system.
Often we make presets at home. With HP or monitors. When you go to rehersal or a gig you turn up and FM-curve comes in. (Thanks to global eq. It saves)
But since there are a lot of amps and ir´s in a modeler, they react different to volume.
With a regular amp/cab there is not that much to relate. Even with that there are a lot of people who are frustated because their amp sound completly different than at home or yesterday. Room, volume, placement, tubes
But as an observer I think it´s strange that anyone would try to change a IMO. Unless you´re drunk, of course..... IMO..
IF the Matrix is really 'more guitar cab sounding' than the CLR, it makes perfect sense that LVC likes it better, regardless of how flat a line is on a graph.
Is this your idea of interpreting a review?
Folks opinions don't matter only Scott's opinion is valid on forums.
If you have an opinion that is not in line with Scott's than you are an idiot and he has a chart to prove it.
So the moral of the story -- please do not disagree with Scott. Your opinions do not matter.
His word is bible around here.
If Scott says it is true -- than it must be true.
Here is my detailed "opinion" piece that you have just mocked. http://forum.fractalaudio.com/amps-...-q12-vs-atomic-clr-active-cab-comparison.html
So when I see this type of behavior from a poster on gear forms --- my little radar goes off