Not to resurrect the horse for another beating, but I feel like I might’ve kicked off that fizz cycle, so…
I really enjoyed hearing lots of different perspectives from people who know more than me, so I don’t see it as a flame war at all. Those kinds of back-and-forth arguments (ie defending your position with evidence) are an excellent thing IMO. If it stays civil, some of us can learn a lot, even just from the clips posted to prove various points. It’s only if it descends to internetitis, ie ad homonym name-calling, that it gets painful, and I don’t think we see that on this forum. Certainly not this thread!
I greatly appreciate everyone who corrected my opinion! I learned a lot, especially from Cliff describing the various phenomena that might get labelled as fizz. I know some people get annoyed by these kind of discussions and say we should just play guitar, and that’s true too, but this to me is what forums are for, and learning things improves my preset skillz which may tangentially improve my playing