Love your ideas/insights. I'm going give this a try.
Right now, I have F3 set to toggle S1/S2. And I have it set in both states (press and press/hold) just so in the heat of battle, if I press the switch too long, nothing bad happens. But I love the idea of 3 scenes along the bottom. Honestly, if scenes are set correctly, I almost never have to think of manual x/y foot taps.
The great thing about the FX8 is that you have complete flexability to set it up whatever way works best for your playing environment.
I go on a song based preset system....& that might sound like a lot at 1st, but it's really not.
EVERYTHING I do is set up left to right per song 1st & foremost. If a song starts w/ a lead, then S1 is that lead scene.....I ususally have S2 set for the chorus of a song w/ a .5 db boost on say the Chorus block. There are lots of little things changing that are not shown on the 4 or 5 button switches & these go on in the background.
I now use the Studio-C reverb block live on almost all of my presets, but I never turn it on/off....So it's not assigned to a switch. If it needs to be OFF all the time, it's set that way in advance.
I've found my core sounds & FX combinations. Most of my song based presets are just a re-ordering of what I alsteady know works.
But.....by having individual song based presets, I never have to worry about messing up a preset for other songs. I do have a handful of songs that have 1-of FX or scenes as well.
I created the Whammy solo for Rage Against the Machines "Killing in the Name" & the very cool "Cherub Rock" solo that has some eunique blocks in it to get it right.
Using this system, my live sets & show go VERY smooth.....& sound spectacular. I'm never screw up or wonder what button to press during a song order wise.
& as always: I make all of my presets, tones & FX mixes at GIG VOLUMES, even if my neighbors HATE me later on! It's the only way to tame high end & get your FX mixes correct.
I NEVER mess with my presets at a live show either. I have built in work arounds in my presets if I need more volume or less of something.
Good luck on your set-up & tone quest. I hope that this helps in some small way & gets you "there" faster.
I am planning on doing an "X's Rig Run Down" very soon since I'm SO in love with my FX8 & Mesa TC50 amp set-up. I'm also willing too help anyone with their rig if I can, just PM me & we'll go from there.
X
Note: Some of my presets only use 1 or 2 scene & I do have a few (Like Rio from Duran Duran) that take 4-scenes in total.
I also like that I can get the FX levels & mix right for each song as some need more delay or less of something in the over-all mix. I've tried a lot of different set-ups w/ the FX8 & this has been just perfect for me. Results will vary....